The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. I, 1898Various
History
The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. I, 1898
Various
American-Irish Historical Society -- Periodicals; Ethnology -- United States -- Periodicals; Irish Americans -- Periodicals
“When these people began coming to America, those families that had
been longest in Ireland had dwelt there but for three generations,
and confusion of mind seems to lurk in any nomenclature which
couples them with the true Irish. The antipathy between the
Scotch-Irish as a group and the true Irish as a group is, perhaps,
unsurpassed for bitterness and intensity. On the other hand, since
love laughs at feuds and schisms, intermarriages between the
Colonists of Ulster and the native Irish were by no means unusual,
and instances occur of Murphys and McManuses of the Presbyterian
faith. It was common in Ulster to allude to Presbyterians as
‘Scotch,’ to Roman Catholics as ‘Irish,’ and to members of the
English Church as ‘Protestants,’ without much reference to pedigree.
From this point of view the term ‘Scotch’ may be defensible,
provided we do not let it conceal the fact that the people to whom
it applied are for the most part Lowland-Scotch Presbyterians, very
slightly hibernicized in blood.”
Again, “By 1719 this hope was torn away, and from that year until
the passage of the Toleration Act for Ireland in 1782, the people of
Ulster kept flocking to America. Of all the migrations to America
previous to the days of steamships this was far the largest in
volume. One week of 1727 landed six ship loads at Philadelphia. In
the two years 1773 and 1774 more than 30,000 came. In 1770 one-third
of the population of Pennsylvania was Scotch-Irish. Altogether
between 1730 and 1770, I think it probable that at least half a
million of souls were transferred from Ulster to the American
Colonies, making not less than one-sixth of our population at the
time of the Revolution.”
The merest examination of this will show that the writer is on
uncertain ground; he is begging the question; his own training and
education convince him that there is a false ring to the term
“Scotch-Irish”; the statements he makes, or quotes, show the
earmarks of that organized humbug the Scotch-Irish Society; and he
is reluctant to face the question squarely, and, by reversing the
conventional concealments, evasions, and falsifications which have
marked the writing of American history in the interest of the
English element, acknowledge the splendid work done by the Irish in
America.
Let us examine his statements in detail.
Relative to Ulster settlement he says: “The settlers were picked men
and women of the most excellent sort. By the middle of the
seventeenth century there were 300,000 of them in Ulster. The
province was a wilderness of bogs and fens; they transformed it into
a garden. They also established manufactures of woolens and linens;
... they were intelligent yeomanry and artisans.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account