The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. IX, 1910Various
History
The journal of the American-Irish Historical Society, Vol. IX, 1910
Various
American-Irish Historical Society -- Periodicals; Ethnology -- United States -- Periodicals; Irish Americans -- Periodicals
It will be interesting to note Washington’s bearing on the subject of
titles while it was under debate in Congress. His position was most
embarrassing and called for tact and equanimity as the first title
considered was that for the President. On its fate depended the granting
of titles for the lesser officers of the government. That Washington
conducted himself with his usual fortitude, impartiality and
broad-mindedness is fully attested by the following entry in Maclay’s
journal: “Through the whole of this base business [granting titles] I
have endeavored to mark the conduct of General Washington. I have no
clew that will fairly lead me to any just conclusion as to his
sentiments. I think it scarce possible but he must have dropped
something on a subject which has excited so much warmth. If he did, it
was not on our side or I would have heard it. But no matter. I have, by
plowing with the heifer of the other House, completely defeated them.”
XVIII.
NO TITLES “FOR THE PRESENT.”
And so ended the momentous debate in the first United States Senate on
the subject of titles which, in one form or another, “engaged almost the
whole time of the Senate from the 23d of April, the day that our
Vice-President began it,” until May 14 when the Senate, by a vote of ten
to eight decided that they, “for the present,” would not press the
subject of titles but so arranged the records as to give the impression
that they sanctioned them. When it came to reading the minutes on the
following day, Friday, May 15, Few moved that the minute on the division
of Lee’s motion be struck out because, as it stood, it had the
appearance of unanimity. Lee opposed. Few was supported by Carroll,
Ellsworth and Maclay—but the minute stood.
One hundred and eighteen years have lapsed since this debate on a title
for the President of the United States—and the consequent “ennobling” of
the lesser officials of the “new” government—took place. That debate
left the situation as follows: the House of Representatives rejected
titles of any kind most positively. The Senate, finding that it could
not bring the whole Congress to the point of giving titles, fell back to
the position that the President and the Senate were the only fountain
heads of titles and that, merely as a matter of accommodation, “for the
present” they waived the question but put themselves on record—by
placing on the files of the Senate a resolution which never was
passed—as being in favor of appellations of nobility.
IRISH PIONEERS OF THE UPPER MISSISSIPPI VALLEY—JOHN WOOD, THE FIRST REAL
PIONEER SETTLER—FOUNDER OF QUINCY, MODEL STATE EXECUTIVE AND
PATRIOT—HEROIC SETTLERS IN VARIOUS STATES.
BY MR. MICHAEL PIGGOTT, QUINCY, ILL.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account