The Kingdom of God is Within You / Christianity and Patriotism / MiscellaniesTolstoy, Leo, graf
Religion
The Kingdom of God is Within You / Christianity and Patriotism / Miscellanies
Tolstoy, Leo, graf
Russian literature -- Translations into English
"DEAR SIR:--When you ask the most peaceable of Academicians
whether he is an advocate of war, his answer is ready in
advance: unfortunately, dear sir, you yourself regard as a dream
the peaceful thoughts which at the present time inspire our
magnanimous countrymen.
"Ever since I have been living in the world, I have heard many
private people express their indignation against this terrifying
habit of international slaughter. All men recognize and deplore
this evil; but how is it to be mended? People have very often
tried to abolish duels,--this seemed so easy! But no! All the
efforts made for the attainment of this end have done no good
and never will do any good.
"No matter how much may be said against war and against duelling
at all the congresses of the world, above all arbitrations,
above all treaties, above all legislations, will eternally stand
man's honour, which has ever demanded duelling, and the national
advantages, which will eternally demand war.
"I none the less with all my heart hope that the Congress
of Universal Peace will succeed in its very grave and very
honourable problem.
"Receive the assurance, etc.
"K. DOUSSET."
The meaning is this, that men's honour demands that people should
fight, and the advantages of the nations demand that they should
ruin and destroy one another, and that the attempts at stopping war
are only worthy of smiles.
Similar is the opinion of another famous man, Jules Claretie:
"Dear Sir," he writes: "For an intelligent man there can exist
but one opinion in respect to the question of peace and war.
"Humanity was created that it should live, being free to
perfect and better (its fate) its condition by means of peaceful
labour. The universal agreement, for which the Universal
Congress of Peace is asking and which it preaches, may present
but a beautiful dream, but it is in any case the most beautiful
dream of all. Man has always before him the promised land of
the future,--the harvest will mature, without fear of harm from
grenades and cannon-wheels.
"But.... Yes, but! Since the world is not ruled by philosophers
and benefactors, it is fortunate that our soldiers protect our
borders and our hearths, and that their arms, correctly aimed,
appear to us, perhaps, as the very best guarantee of this peace,
which is so fervently loved by all of us.
"Peace is given only to the strong and the determined.
"Receive the assurance, etc.
"J. CLARETIE."
The meaning of this is, that it does no harm to talk of what no one
intends to do, and what ought not to be done at all. But when it
comes to business, we must fight.
Here is another recent expression of opinion concerning war, by the
most popular novelist of Europe, E. Zola:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account