The Knickerbocker, Vol. 22, No. 1, July 1843Various
General
The Knickerbocker, Vol. 22, No. 1, July 1843
Various
Periodicals
They were withheld originally from publication; the fastidious
taste of the writer suggesting infelicities, which we are certain
will escape the scrutiny of less refined critics of 'the gentle art
of song.' * * * SOME newspaper 'down east' has been instigated to
hint that the lively and gossipping New-York correspondence of the
Washington 'National Intelligencer' is written by JOHN NEAL! As if
it were possible to mistake the pleasant style of Mr. WILLIS, for
the labored yet slovenly _no-style_ of 'OMNIUM SCRIBLERIUS!' One
might as well attribute the authorship of 'Thanatopsis' to 'Sir
WILLIAM MARSH, of Apple Island, Boston Harbor!' * * * THE paper
elicited by the article upon '_Forensic Eloquence_' in our last
number, is somewhat too kindred in character with that excellent
performance, to be at present admissible. As the MS. is left to our
option, however, with permission to 'add, clip, or destroy,' we
annex a passage which will be new to many of our readers:
'CÆSAR, who was himself an accomplished orator, and knew all the
windings of the art, was so shaken on the occasion of TULLY's
oration, that he trembled, dropped his papers, and acquitted
the prisoner. Many attributed this to the force of TULLY's
elocution; but it seems rather to have been the effect of
CÆSAR's art. He played back the orator's art upon himself. His
concern was feigned, and his mercy artificial; as he knew that
nothing could so effectually win TULLY to his party, as giving
him the pride of having conquered CÆSAR.' In relation to the
different _styles_ of eloquence, the same writer observes: 'The
pathetic orator who throws a congregation of enthusiasts into
tears and groanings, would raise affections of a very different
nature, should he attempt to proselyte an American congress;
and on the other hand, the finest speaker that ever commanded
the House, would in vain point the thunder of his eloquence on
a Quaker meeting. VOLTAIRE tells us, that 'in France a sermon
is a long declamation, spoken with rapture and enthusiasm; in
Italy, it is a kind of devotional comedy; in England, it is
a solid dissertation, sometimes a dry one, which is read to
the congregation without action or elocution.' A discourse
which would raise a French audience to the highest pitch of
enthusiasm, would throw an English one into a fit of laughter.'
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account