The Knickerbocker, Vol. 22, No. 3, September 1843Various
General
The Knickerbocker, Vol. 22, No. 3, September 1843
Various
Periodicals
'THE poem,' says the author of this miniature pamphlet-volume, 'of
which the four first cantos (he means the _first four_, no doubt)
are here submitted to the reader, was chiefly the work of the
writer's youth.' He does not claim, however, that this fact forms
any sufficient excuse for giving it to the public at this late
day; but offers rather the natural tenacity 'with which the mind
treasures up, and seeks to preserve, the performances which revive
its early associations.' We have run through these cantos with some
attention. The story does not strike us as possessing either great
originality or interest. The verse itself is after the model of 'Don
Juan,' then recently published, and rife in the literary world; but
like the thousand-and-one imitations which we have encountered of
that most facile and felicitous composition, its 'laborious ease'
cannot be concealed. With BYRON, the play of fancy and of words was
equally unconstrained, in this species of versification; but all his
imitators have evidently been stretched upon Procrustean beds; and
with all the seeming _abandon_ of their manner, and the smirk of
their 'varnished faces,' it has yet been but too evident that their
situation was any thing but comfortable. In 'Donna Florida' however
there is a good degree of cleverness. There are many thoughts
interspersed throughout its cantos which the reader will encounter
with surprise and remember with pleasure. Nevertheless we are
compelled to say, that where the stanzas are most original, they are
the least to our liking. We enter our protest against the writer's
frequent habit of saying a plain thing in an involved, roundabout
way, as well as against numerous words and similes which he employs.
'You can call a hat,' says Mr. YELLOWPLUSH, a 'glossy four-and-nine'
or a 'swart sombréro;' but in the long run praps it's as well to
call it _a hat_. It _is_ a hat; and where's the use o' mystifying?'
Would it not, for example, be 'as well' also, and quite as natural,
to write 'half of the rest,' as 'the subdivision of the remaining
moïety?' Or in saying that old jokes were laughed at, to express it
in less magniloquent phrase than
'Old jokes _found revivified expansion_?'
Where does Mr. SIMMS find authority for such a word as
'_voicing_?'--'the voicings of a bird?' In any dictionary of the
English language? Guess not! As little do we admire the simile which
makes a lady's eye the 'polar light in love's astrology,' or which
represents it as
----'peering beneath her forehead like a star,
Bestowing a sweet glory on the sky.'
All these are 'affectations, look you;' and are in our judgment
even worse sins against taste (to say nothing of truth) than the
occasional instances of an opposite tendency which might be pointed
out; such as 'the beast enjoying his _grunt and stye_;' or the coy
damsel, of whom the writer says:
'One moment grows she most abruptly willing,
The next, she _slaps the chaps that think of billing_!'
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account