To this Taylor well replied: "This criticism seems unjust. The cruelty of Roderick's raids in the Lowlands has already been hinted at, and the sight of the Lowland dress might well stir associations in the poor girl's mind which would lead her to look to the knight for help and protection and also to warn him of his danger. It is plain, from Murdoch's surprise, that her being out of her captors' sight is looked on as dangerous, from which we may infer that she is not entirely crazed. Her song is not the only hint that Fitz-James follows. His suspicions had already twice been excited, so that the episode seems natural enough. As giving a distinct personal ground for the combat in canto v., it serves the poet's purpose still further. Without it, we should sympathize too much with the robber chief, who thinks that 'plundering Lowland field and fold is naught but retribution true;' but the sight of this sad fruit of his raids wins us back to the cause of law and order." 614. Forth at full speed, etc. The MS. reads: "Forth at full speed the Clansman went, But in his race his bow he bent, Halted--and back an arrow sent." 617. Thrilled. Quivered. 627. Thine ambushed kin, etc. The MS. transposes this line and the next, and goes on thus: "Resistless as the lightning's flame, The thrust betwixt his shoulder came." Just below it reads: "The o'er him hung, with falcon eye, And grimly smiled to see him die." 642. Daggled. Wet, soaked. Cf. the Lay, i. 316: "Was daggled by the dashing spray." 649. Helpless. The MS. has "guiltless." 657. Shred. Cut off; a sense now obsolete. Cf. Withal's Dictionary (ed. 1608): "The superfluous and wast sprigs of vines, being cut and shreaded off are called sarmenta." 659. My brain, etc. The MS. has "But now, my champion, it shall wave." 672. Wreak. Avenge. Cf. Shakespeare, R. and J. iii. 5. 102: "To wreak the love I bore my cousin Upon his body that hath slaughter'd him;" Spenser, F. Q. ii. 3. 13: "to wreak so foule despight;" etc. 679. God, in my need, etc. The MS. reads: "God, in my need, to me be true, As I wreak this on Roderick Dhu." 686. Favor. The token of the next line; referring to the knightly custom of wearing such a gift of lady-love or mistress. Cf. Rich. II. v. 3. 18: "And from the common'st creature pluck a glove, And wear it as a favour," etc. See also the Lay, iv. 334: "With favor in his crest, or glove, Memorial of his layde-love." 691. At bay. See on i. 133 above; and for the dangerous foe, cf. the note on i. 137. 698. Couched him. Lay down. See on i. 142 above. 700. Rash adventures. See on 437 above. 701. Must prove. The 1st ed. has "will prove." 705. Bands at Doune. Cf. 150 above. 711. Darkling. See on 283 above. 722. Not the summer solstice. Not even the heat of the summer. 724. Wold. See on 267 above. 731. Beside its embers, etc. The MS. reads: