The Law and Medical MenRogers, R. Vashon (Robert Vashon)
History
The Law and Medical Men
Rogers, R. Vashon (Robert Vashon)
Medical laws and legislation
It is a well settled doctrine that where one occupies a position
which naturally gives him the confidence of another, or which in any
way gives him an influence, or an undue advantage over the other,
transactions between them require something more to give them validity
than is necessary in other cases. The mere fact of the existence of
such a relationship as naturally creates influence over the mind will
lead the courts to infer the probability of undue influence having
been exerted. Confidence has been held to imply the opportunity for
influence, and when established, dispenses with any more direct
proof of influence. In such cases the _onus_ is cast upon the person
occupying such a relationship to establish the perfect fairness and
equity of the transaction. He must shew that the other acted after full
and sufficient deliberation and with all the information that it was
material for him to have, in order to guide his conduct, and that he
had either independent and disinterested advice, or as ample protection
as such advice could have given him [368]. _Rhodes_ v. _Bates_ [369] lays
it down that the donor must have had competent and independent advice.
The relation between a medical man and his patient is one in which
the probability of undue influence is inferred; |139| and so in
dealings with their patients the acts of physicians are watched with
great jealousy; not because the Court blames and discountenances the
influence flowing from such relation, but because it holds that this
influence should be exerted for the benefit of the person subject to
it, and not for the advantage of the person possessing it [370]. The
discontinuance of the relationship is only material if the influence
has ceased with the relation; and the relation does not necessarily
cease because the patient has not medicine actually administered to him
at the time [371].
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account