The Law and Medical MenRogers, R. Vashon (Robert Vashon)
History
The Law and Medical Men
Rogers, R. Vashon (Robert Vashon)
Medical laws and legislation
If a medical man takes upon himself the responsibility of imprisoning
a person on the ground of insanity, upon mere statements made to him
by others, he will be liable to an action, and also for an assault,
unless he can indeed show that the party imprisoned was insane at
the time [395]. He is not liable for an assault if he has signed a
certificate under the Lunacy Acts and has done nothing more towards
causing the confinement of the alleged lunatic [396]. A medical man
or other person may justify an assault where it is committed for the
purpose of putting a restraint upon a dangerous lunatic in such a state
that it is likely he may do mischief to some one [397].
In Ontario, except under order of the Lieutenant-Governor, no one
can be admitted into a lunatic asylum without the certificate of
three medical men, each attested by the signatures of two subscribing
witnesses. Their certificates must state a personal and separate
examination, and that after due enquiry the patient was found insane;
and the physicians must also specify the facts upon which they formed
their opinion of the insanity. In England, except in the case of
paupers, two certificates are required [398].
The practice of abortion is forbidden by the oath of Hippocrates. The
act is recognized as a crime in almost every code of medical ethics:
its known commission has always been followed by ignominious expulsion
from medical fellowship and fraternity. At Common Law a child _en
ventre sa mere_ is not considered a person the killing of whom is
murder; but if one, intending to procure abortion, causes a child to be
born so soon that it cannot live, and |147| it dies in consequence,
it is murder [399]. And it is murder if one, attempting to procure
abortion, either by means of drugs or instruments, cause the death of
the woman [400].
In most civilized countries it is now either a felony, or grave
misdemeanor, to attempt to procure the miscarriage of a woman by any
means; or to supply or procure any thing knowing that it is intended
to be unlawfully used or employed to procure a miscarriage [401]. In
some States the crime of abortion may be committed at any stage of
pregnancy [402]. The thing prescribed must be noxious in its nature, but
it is not necessary to prove that it will produce miscarriage [403].
The burden of shewing that the use of instruments to produce abortion
was necessary to save the life of the woman is on the accused [404].
It is an indictable offence for a physician, or any one else,
unlawfully and injuriously to carry along or to expose in a public
highway, on which persons are passing, and near to the habitations
of others, any person infected with the small-pox, or any contagious
disorder; and it is for the accused to shew that the object of the
carrying or exposure was lawful [405].
In England, since 1840, it has been an indictable offence to innoculate
for the small-pox [406]. So, too, it has been in Canada for a number of
years [407]. |148|
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account