Law -- England; Poor -- England; Poor laws -- England; Working class -- England
The current cant of the day is that the alehouse leads to the workhouse.
From an architectural and hygienic point of view they have much in common,
and perhaps when one comes to spend one's last years amid the unloveliness
and official squareness and coldness of the workhouse one will be able to
look back with a sense of grateful pleasure to the more natural squalor of
the alehouse. It is a zoological fact that the human pauper, escaped for
the day from a workhouse, makes like a homing bird for the alehouse,
wherefrom we may draw the conclusion that the public for whom our two
public houses are provided by an intelligent State prefer the alehouse as
the lesser abomination of the two.
I often wonder if there is any nation in the world that possesses an
appetite equal to that of our own people for Royal Commissions and
reports. I admit that I have the craving strongly myself--not to sit upon
Commissions, for I am a working man and the amusement is one for Bishops,
Law Lords, philanthropists and the leisured classes--but I buy the reports
when they come out and sometimes read them--or some of them--or some part
of them--and marvel at the patience and energy and research that have gone
to the making of them, and sigh over the pity of it and the heart-breaking
inutility of the whole business.
Here is the report of the Royal Commission on the Poor Laws, 1909. The
blue cover of my copy is already turning grey with old age, the pencil
marks I made in the margin when I read it five years ago remind me of the
splendid reforms that spread themselves out in its pages and made one feel
that after all the world was a better affair than one had hitherto
believed. This report is indeed literally a monument of industry. It sat
from 1905 to 1909. There are over twelve hundred pages in the report
itself, which you can buy for the trumpery sum of five and six. The
evidence of it is contained in many volumes, and if your library is large
enough and you can afford to pay the price of a large paper set, you would
have reading enough for the rest of your natural life. And what has come
of it all? Practically nothing. It is not to be supposed that either the
report or the evidence has ever been read and studied by our ministers and
rulers. A few magazine and newspaper articles have been made of it, then
perhaps a book or two are written on the subject, the origin of which you
can trace to the report, and after that gradually the thing sinks by its
own cumbrous weight into the dead limbo of forgotten state papers. Yet if
there was a problem called the reform of the Poor Law in 1905 worthy of
the consideration of the good men and women who gave up a large slice of
their lives to working at it surely in 1914 there is still such a problem,
and some of it is at least as urgent as the questions over which our
political pastors wrangle and fight with such splendid energy. To write an
essay on the law and the poor in relation to the relief of distress would
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account