The Life & Letters of Peter Ilich TchaikovskyChaikovskii, Modest
General
The Life & Letters of Peter Ilich Tchaikovsky
Chaikovskii, Modest
Composers -- Russia -- Biography; Tchaikovsky, Peter Ilich, 1840-1893
“I am still in Vienna. Yesterday I heard that my servant would
leave Moscow on Saturday. Although I have given him the most minute
instructions what to do on the journey, I have no idea how he will
cross the frontier, not knowing a single word of any foreign
language. I fancy there will be many tragic-comic episodes.
Sometimes I think it is not very wise to have a Russian servant.
And yet--I do not know what I should have done, since I cannot
endure complete solitude. Besides which I know it will be a comfort
to my brother to feel I am not quite alone. I have seen Wagner’s
_Walküre_. The performance was excellent. The orchestra surpassed
itself; the best singers did all within their powers--and yet it
was wearisome. What a Don Quixote is Wagner! He expends his whole
force in pursuing the impossible, and all the time, if he would but
follow the natural bent of his extraordinary gift, he might evoke a
whole world of musical beauties. In my opinion Wagner is a
symphonist by nature. He is gifted with genius which has wrecked
itself upon his tendencies; his inspiration is paralysed by
theories which he has invented on his own account, and which,
_nolens volens_, he wants to bring into practice. In his efforts to
attain _reality_, _truth_, and _rationalism_ he lets _music_ slip
quite out of sight, so that in his four latest operas it is, more
often than not, conspicuous by its absence. I cannot call that
music which consists of kaleidoscopic, shifting phrases, which
succeed each other without a break and never come to a close, that
is to say, never give the ear the least chance to rest upon musical
form. Not a single broad, rounded melody, nor yet one moment of
repose for the singer! The latter must always pursue the orchestra,
and be careful never to lose his note, which has no more importance
in the score than some note for the fourth horn. But there is no
doubt Wagner is a wonderful symphonist. I will just prove to you by
one example how far the symphonic prevails over the operatic style
in his operas. You have probably heard his celebrated
_Walkürenritt_? What a great and marvellous picture! How we
actually seem to see these fierce heroines flying on their magic
steeds amid thunder and lightning! In the concert-room this piece
makes an extraordinary impression. On the stage, in view of the
cardboard rocks, the canvas clouds, and the soldiers who run about
very awkwardly in the background--in a word, seen in this very
inadequate theatrical heaven, which makes a poor pretence of
realising the illimitable realms above, the music loses all its
powers of expression. Here the stage does not enhance the effect,
but acts rather like a wet blanket. Finally I cannot understand,
and never shall, why the _Nibelungen_ should be considered a
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account