The Life of Ludwig van Beethoven, Volume IIThayer, Alexander Wheelock
History
The Life of Ludwig van Beethoven, Volume II
Thayer, Alexander Wheelock
Beethoven, Ludwig van, 1770-1827
[Sidenote: ILL FEELING BETWEEN BEETHOVEN AND HUMMEL]
The Mass was produced on the next day--the 13th. “It was the custom at
this court,” says Schindler,
that after the religious service the local as well as foreign
musical notabilities met in the chambers of the Prince for the
purpose of conversing with him about the works which had been
performed. When Beethoven entered the room, the Prince turned
to him with the question: “But, my dear Beethoven, what is this
that you have done again?” The impression made by this singular
question, which was probably followed by other critical remarks,
was the more painful on our artist because he saw the chapelmaster
standing near the Prince laugh. Thinking that he was being
ridiculed, nothing could keep him at the place where his work had
been so misunderstood and besides, as he thought, where a brother
in art had rejoiced over his discomfiture. He left Eisenstadt the
same day.
The laughing chapelmaster was J. N. Hummel, who had been called to
the post in 1804 in place of Haydn, recently pensioned because of his
infirmities, due to old age. Schindler continues:
Thence dates the falling-out with Hummel, between whom and
Beethoven there never existed a real intimate friendship.
Unfortunately they never came to an explanation which might have
disclosed that the unlucky laugh was not directed at Beethoven,
but at the singular manner in which the Prince had criticized the
mass (in which there is still much that might be complained of).
But there were other things which fed the hate of Beethoven. One of
these was that the two had an inclination for the same girl; the
other, the tendency which Hummel had first introduced not only in
pianoforte playing but also composition.... Not until the last days
of Beethoven, ~post tot discrimina rerum~, was the cloud which had
settled between the two artists dispelled.
In the earlier editions of his book, Schindler gives a still gloomier
tinge to the story:
His hatred of Hummel because of this (the laugh after the mass) was
so deeply rooted that I know of no second one like it in his entire
history. After the lapse of 14 years he told me the story with a
bitterness as if it had happened the day before. But this dark
cloud was dissipated by the strength of his spirit, and this would
have happened much earlier had Hummel approached him in a friendly
manner instead of always holding himself aloof.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account