"Mr. Lincoln has not character enough for integrity and truth merely
on his own ipse dixit to arraign President Buchanan, President
Pierce and nine Judges of the Supreme Court, not one of whom would
be complimented by being put on an equality with him. There is
an unpardonable presumption in any man putting himself up before
thousands of people and pretending that his ipse dixit, without
proof, without fact and without truth, is enough to bring down and
destroy the purest and best of living men. * * * The word 'State'
as well as 'Territory' was put into the Nebraska bill to knock in
the head this Abolition doctrine that there will be no more slave
States even if the people want them. * * * The people of Missouri
formed a Constitution as a slave State and asked admission into the
Union; but the Free Soil party of the North, being in a majority,
refused to admit her because she had slavery as one of her
institutions. Hence, the first slavery agitation arouse upon a
State and not upon a Territory. * * * The whole Abolition agitation
arose on that doctrine of prohibiting a State from coming in with
slavery or not as it pleased, and that same doctrine is here in
this Republican platform of 1854."
The peculiar difficult of meeting Douglas in argument before a
popular audience is here exhibited in its most perfect form. The
persuasive force of his last proposition lay in a most ingenious
play on the words "State" and "Territory." Although the people
of Missouri had formed a State Constitution, they did not become
a State until Congress approved it and formally admitted them.
During the entire period of dispute they continued a Territory.
Douglas' argument assumes that they became a State on forming a
Constitution.
Chapter XV. The Debates with Lincoln Continued.
The second debate was held at Freeport on August 27th. Lincoln
opened his speech with a series of answers to the questions asked
at Ottawa.
"I do not," he said, * * * "stand in favor of the unconditional
repeal of the Fugitive Slave law. * * *
"I do not * * * stand pledged against the admission of
any more slave States into the Union. * * * *
"I do not stand pledged against the admission of a new State. *
* * with such a Constitutions as the people * * * may see
fit to make. * * *
"I do not stand pledged to the abolition of slavery in
the District of Columbia. * * *
"I'm impliedly, if not expressly, pledged to a belief in the right
and duty of Congress to prohibit slavery in all the United
States Territories. * * *
"I am not opposed to the honest acquisition of territory. * * * I
would or would not oppose such acquisition accordingly as I might
think such acquisition would or would not aggravate the slavery
question among ourselves."
The questions asked and answered were, whether he was PLEDGED to
any of these things. He was willing, however, to state what he
really thought of them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account