The Life of the Rev. George Whitefield, Volume 1 (of 2)Tyerman, L. (Luke)
History
The Life of the Rev. George Whitefield, Volume 1 (of 2)
Tyerman, L. (Luke)
Whitefield, George, 1714-1770
Want of space makes it impossible to give an outline of Mr.
Seagrave's reply to Dr. Trapp; but three brief extracts from this
scarce production may be welcome.
"Little or nothing was objected to the Methodists, by the
clergy, while they continued _in_ our churches, excepting
some disorders and inconveniences arising, by their means, to
our places of worship; but, from the time they unexpectedly
undertook to preach in fields, and in a manner not altogether
favourable to _ecclesiastical maxims_ and _church authority_,
they have commenced impostors, enthusiasts, and novelists. They
have likewise acquired very additional blame for asserting
that they discern several valuable and worthy Christians
amongst Dissenters of every branch. To which I reply: (1) Does
preaching in a field _annul_ that character or _commission_
of a minister, in all respects ordained like the rest, which
divines themselves call an _indelible character_? A discovery
seems to be made, that the exercise of a minister's function
subsists no longer than he shall _absolutely_ coincide with
the majority of his brethren, or shall _think_ as his diocesan
_thinks_. (2) The Dissenters have mostly _kept_ the old truths
which _now_ begin to be discovered. Why should we confine _all_
religion, and _all_ learning, and _all_ knowledge to our _own_
Church? The Methodists think they see _more_ religion and real
knowledge at present amongst the Dissenters than (I am sorry to
say it) is _commonly_ seen in our own Church; and they have the
impartiality not to deny it."
"I shall not deny that instances of folly are imputable to the
Methodists. Persons have sung psalms in streets and corners; an
indiscretion this, but no crime. We ought to balance the _bad_
part with the _good_. Nothing but obstinacy and envy can deny
that a _great_ reformation has arisen upon the manners of the
age by the _itinerant's_ preaching. If the gospel be preached
in the church, it is well and desirable; but, when our clergy
_leave the old truths_, and are fallen into the scheme of Deism,
though they may not discern it, men have a right to hear the
truth in _the field_, or in a _meeting-house_, supposing they
can find it nowhere else."
One more extract, partly aimed at Dr. Trapp as a pluralist, must
suffice.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account