Perhaps it is the influence of Wordsworth that still spreads this
confusion in our writing. The effect of many of his best known poems
has never been wholly satisfactory, not even to his admirers; he drew
moral lessons from objects humble or mean, and since his own interest
was in the moral lesson, he sometimes was careless of the emotional
appeal which the object, left standing as it were in the poem, might
make on the reader. In one sense he was not a nature-lover, though he
had recourse to nature for ethical wisdom; it was only the wisdom he
cared about, and we have an unpleasant impression, which perhaps does
him injustice, that when he had got a moral idea out of the primrose
by the river’s brim, he was through with the primrose for the day. The
same impression, unfortunately, is made by his portrayal of humble or
mean characters. He obviously does not identify his better fortunes
with their misery, nor does he enter dramatically or imaginatively into
their lives; he is content to draw a moral from them, and the reader,
in his day and still in ours, is surprised that misery in the picture,
having produced a moral, is promptly dropped as though of no further
concern. The old leech-gatherer serves a purpose when his courage
against frightful odds cheers up a moodish poet; the old beggar at the
door moves us to gratitude that another man’s poverty keeps fresh in
us our springs of charity. Much good this does the leech-gatherer or
the beggar! And if there is to be no help for them, their presence is a
bit disturbing in the background of so much complacence. We wish there
were more tenderness in these poems that talk so much of feeling. And
when Wordsworth deliberately sets out to enlist our admiration for the
heroic, we may find ourselves facing such dumb human misery as we have
in _Michael_, the heroism of a wrecked family and an abandoned farm.
With relief we turn to the passages in the _Prelude_ where the poet no
longer looks down benignly on the wretched, but gives expression to the
ideal life which he himself desires to attain; there, where he shows life
better than it is, we can go with him and lose ourselves in the vision.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account