Authors are not at all agreed respecting the period at which this wall
was erected. Gibbon, relying apparently on the testimony of Duhalde
(Description de la China, tom. ii. p. 45) and Deguignes (Hist. des
Huns, tom. ii. p. 59), gives the third century before the Christian
era as the date of its construction, and assigns it a length of
fifteen hundred miles.—(History, vol. iv. p. 361.) Du Pauw, an
ingenious but conceited and coxcombical writer, makes no objection to
the antiquity of the work, but reduces its length to about four
hundred and fifty miles; and this without citing any authority, or
even stating his reasons, except that he does not choose to consider
the western branch, which, he tells us, is built of earth, worthy the
name of a wall.—(Recherch. Phil. sur les Egypt. et Chin. tom. ii. p.
77-79.) For my own part, I am inclined to agree with those writers who
think it an entirely modern work, erected since the thirteenth
century; for the silence of Marco Polo appears to me absolutely
decisive. Du Pauw’s supposition that he could have entered China from
Mongolia, that is, passed through the wall, and lived eighteen years
in the country, which he traversed in every direction, without once
hearing of its existence, is too absurd even for refutation. That he
abstained from describing it, lest he should excite a suspicion of the
truth of his narrative, though somewhat more probable perhaps, does
not upon the whole seem credible. If it existed in his time, I can
account for his silence, or rather for the absence of all mention of
it in his travels, as they at present exist, only by supposing that
the passage in which this extraordinary work was alluded to, was, like
many other passages, omitted from ignorant incredulity by
transcribers, and so lost. Thus, too, we may account for no mention of
tea being found in his travels.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account