The logic of modern physicsBridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Philosophy
The logic of modern physics
Bridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Physics -- Philosophy
With this bias we now turn to examine the facts of rotary motion, and
are disconcerted to find them quite different. No meaning in terms of
measuring operations can be given to absolute rotary motion any more
than to absolute translation, but nevertheless phenomena are obviously
entirely different in different systems in relative rotary motion
(phenomena of rupture, for example), so that apparently there are
physical phenomena by which the concept of absolute rotary motion might
be given a certain physical significance. Given two worlds like our own
in empty space, but surrounded by impenetrable clouds, and each provided
with a Foucault pendulum, then we believe that it is physically possible
that we may find on one of these worlds the plane of rotation of the
pendulum gradually changing in direction, while on the other it remains
stationary. This difference we regard as possible without other
accompanying physical phenomena which are causally related to the
rotation of the pendulum (of course we have to make the two worlds of
infinitely rigid material and eliminate other phenomena which we regard
as purely incidental), so that we apparently have here a contradiction
of our cardinal physical principle of essential connectivity. We are
certainly not inclined to give up our principle, and we believe that as
a physical fact, if the clouds could be evaporated, an observer in one
world would find that he was rotating with respect to the system of the
fixed stars, whereas the corresponding observer on the other world would
find that he was stationary. Our principle of essential connectivity is
therefore maintained, in that the rotation of the plane of the pendulum
is connected with a rotation with respect to the rest of the universe of
the entire world in which the pendulum is mounted. As far as I am aware,
no other way of maintaining our principle has ever been suggested. But
this demands that we give up our physical hypothesis of the possibility
of isolating a system. There is here no question of limiting behavior;
we believe that no matter how far our rotating world gets from the rest
of the universe the Foucault pendulum would always behave in the same
way; the system can never be isolated, but such local phenomena as the
invariance of the plane of the pendulum are always essentially
determined by the rest of the universe.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account