The logic of modern physicsBridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Philosophy
The logic of modern physics
Bridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Physics -- Philosophy
Finally, we must comment on the general tactics of the quantum
situation. It would seem that there have already been a sufficient
number of unsuccessful attempts to formulate quantum behavior in terms
of ordinary mechanics to justify the expectation that ultimately
something quite different must evolve. The difficulties of an unmodified
carrying over of ordinary mechanical notions to quantum phenomena may be
illustrated by a simple example. Consider a particle of mass _m_
rotating in a frictionless circular track of radius _r_. Then according
to quantum conditions it can move stably on this track only with certain
definite velocities, such that ∫ pdq = mv 2πr = nh. Suppose now the
particle rotating with one of the allowed velocities, and a tangential
force applied. If the usual mechanical notions of force are still valid,
the particle must respond by moving in its track with continually
increasing velocity. After the velocity has been increased by a small
amount, we remove the force. The motion is now no longer one of the
allowed ones, and the particle must in some way change its velocity; it
must either slow down or speed up. In the first case it must either
radiate energy, which a system of the simple mechanical properties we
have supposed is not capable of doing, or else the law of conservation
of energy fails, and also Newton's first law of motion during the
process of acquiring the steady condition. If, on the other hand, the
particle speeds up, it must increase its energy from nowhere, and again
ordinary mechanics does not apply.
It seems then a mistake to attempt to formulate the quantum conditions
in terms of the notions of ordinary mechanics (momentum, and position
coördinates in either the ordinary or the generalized Lagrangean
sense). It would seem, on the other hand, plausible to expect that
mechanics is not a fundamental thing, but is in some way an effect
produced by the aggregate action of a great many elementary quantum
processes. Amplitude of radiational vibration, for example, may be such
a statistical aspect of a great many processes, in some such way as on
the ordinary level of experience temperature is a statistical aspect of
the average kinetic energy of the atoms. One possibility of this kind
has already been more explicitly indicated; in the elementary process of
emission of radiation, frequency and energy are not two independently
assignable variables, but are connected [E = hν]. That is, on the
quantum level radiation has only a single property, which is properly
neither energy or frequency. [We are now neglecting the polarization
aspect of radiation.] On a higher level, that of ordinary radiation, the
single elementary property has expanded itself into two (energy and
frequency) through the additional variable of the number of elementary
quantum processes in the complex radiation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account