The logic of modern physicsBridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Philosophy
The logic of modern physics
Bridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Physics -- Philosophy
We now ask what significance is to be ascribed to the sort of
conservation that energy does have. We restrict ourselves first to
mechanical systems. The motions of a mechanical system satisfy certain
differential equations of the second order, and the actual motion is to
be found by an integration of the equations. In the integral of a
differential equation certain constants appear which are determined by
the initial conditions, and are therefore the same during all the future
motion of the system; obviously these constants of motion correspond to
conservative properties. This reasoning can of course be at once
extended. Any system, mechanical or not, whose motion is determined by
differential equations, will have certain conservative properties. For
the systems of mechanics energy is one of the conservative functions;
others are momentum and moment of momentum. Energy is particularly
simple, in that it is connected with measurable properties of the system
by a simple formula (∑ ½ mv^2), and is furthermore scalar, which is
also a property of quantity of matter. But to go further and ascribe to
energy other properties of matter, such as localization in space, is
entirely overlooking the essential difference in the character of the
operation by which matter and quantity of energy are measured, that is,
overlooking the essential difference in their physical character.
The possible extension of the energy concept from mechanics to
thermodynamics receives a sufficient physical explanation in terms of
our views of the essentially mechanical character of thermal phenomena.
That the idea can be extended also to simple electrical or magnetic
systems, in which the effect of velocity of propagation is neglected, is
a consequence of the fact that in these systems the equations of motion
remain of the same general mechanical type, it having been shown by
Maxwell that the equations of such systems may be written in the
generalized Lagrangean form. When, however, we extend our formulas to
systems in which the velocity of propagation is important (that is, when
we consider the field equations in their general form) we find that the
Lagrangean equations no longer apply to matter taken by itself, and
energy is no longer conserved in the original sense. A new function
appears, however, which behaves mathematically in the same way that the
energy did before. The equations of motion of the system remain
Lagrangean in form if the mechanical parts of the system are
supplemented by the electric and magnetic fields in space. In this
extended form we have, therefore, a conservative function as before, and
the energy concept may be retained in this enlarged aspect. The physical
operations by which energy is determined are entirely altered, however,
and the physical character of the concept is changed. No more than
before is there justification for localizing energy in space, or
ascribing to it other properties of matter. Yet the materialization of
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account