The Logic of Vegetarianism: Essays and DialoguesSalt, Henry S.
Philosophy
The Logic of Vegetarianism: Essays and Dialogues
Salt, Henry S.
Vegetarianism
"impracticable" for the strange reason that, unlike most
_isms_, it asks them to do something individually which they
know they _could_ do—if they wished! It is impracticable
because it does not suit them to practise it.
REFORMER: Let me entreat you; give up this fanciful
scheme of vegetarianism and come and work for social
reform.
VEGETARIAN: Social reform without food reform! Is not
that rather a lame and lop-sided business?
REFORMER: Not at all. When we have so many things to do
we must do the most important ones first.
VEGETARIAN: And what are the most important?
REFORMER: Well, there is international peace and
arbitration. You will admit that our first duty is to
avoid unnecessary bloodshed.
VEGETARIAN: Ah, I see! And the habit of _living_ by
bloodshed doesn't come within your scope!
REFORMER: Then there is the land question, and the need
of relieving the congestion of our crowded cities by the
revival of agriculture.
VEGETARIAN: So, of course, you can't attend to a
diet-system which would bring people back to the land!
REFORMER: There is also the temperance problem—the
terrible evils of the drink crave.
VEGETARIAN: Which would disappear for the most part if
we left off eating flesh.
REFORMER: And the welfare of animals—for to that also I
devote myself. We need some stringent legislation for
the better prevention of cruelty.
VEGETARIAN: We do. But as such legislation would leave
your reformers dinnerless, don't you think you should
revise your dietary meantime? Your reforms are
excellent, I grant you; but what of _self-reform_? Does
not reform, like charity, begin at home?
REFORMER: Well, well; to everyone his taste—reform or
self-reform. I prefer the former; you the latter, I
suppose.
VEGETARIAN: No; that is just where you are mistaken. I
prefer both at once.
Reform _and_ self-reform, not reform _or_ self-reform—that is
the true key to the solution of the social question. The work
that we can do ourselves is the most wholesome condiment for the
work that we can only do through society. And here let me
express the hope that, as a matter of policy, vegetarians will
stand aloof from all "philanthropic" schemes of _vicarious_ food
reform in prisons, reformatories, and workhouses; for there is
no surer way of making a principle unpopular than by forcing it
on the poor and helpless, while carefully avoiding it one's
self. Philanthropists, if they be philanthropists, will practise
what they preach; by their practice we shall know them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account