The Louvre: Fifty Plates in ColourBrockwell, Maurice W.
History
The Louvre: Fifty Plates in Colour
Brockwell, Maurice W.
Musée du Louvre
El Greco’s conception of portraiture enters largely into his pictures
at the Louvre, from which we must exclude as an imitation by an
inferior hand the _St. Francis and a Novice_ (No. 1729A). It is
certainly an important feature in the large _Christ on the Cross, with
Two Donors_, one of the comparatively recent acquisitions, which still
hangs on a screen in Gallery XV. This great altarpiece has little
of the master’s fierce passion and lightning flashes of colour. The
expression of the two Donors, Diego and Antonio Covarrubias, who are
seen to the waist at the foot of the Cross, does not go beyond normal
pious devotion; and the Saviour seems rather to stand with spread arms
than to hang on the Cross with all the weight of His characteristically
elongated body. A leaden grey dominates the whole colour scheme. The
composition is singularly empty and simple for a master who seemed to
have a perfect horror of empty spaces. The picture, which is fully
signed, must have been painted soon after El Greco’s arrival at Toledo
(and not, as Sñr. Cossío thinks, between 1590 and 1600), since one of
the Donors, the priest Diego Covarrubias, died in 1577.
Comparison of the two Donors’ faces with their portraits by the same
master in the Toledo Library can leave no doubt as to their identity.
The _Christ on the Cross_ was offered by the deputy Isaac Pereire
of Prades (Pyrenées-Orientales) to the local parish church, but was
refused and hung in the Palais de Justice at Prades, whence it was
removed to the Mairie in 1904, and finally sold to the Louvre in 1908
for £1000. The picture measures 8 ft. 8 in. by 5 ft. 8 in.
The _St. Louis of France and a Page_ (No. 1729B), which was formerly
wrongly catalogued as _King Ferdinand the Catholic_, is a more typical
example of El Greco’s management of colour. The boldly painted armour
is identical with that of the St. Martin on horseback, at Toledo. The
probable date of the picture, which was bought in 1904 at the high
price of £2800, is between 1594 and 1600.
By El Greco’s favourite pupil and assistant, Luis Tristan (1586-1640),
is the realistic half-figure of _St. Francis of Assisi_ (No. 1730).
A more scientific classification of the works by the Toledo painters
has reversed Sir W. Stirling-Maxwell’s judgment that Tristan had all
the virtues and none of the faults of his master. He was in reality a
mediocre imitator of El Greco, without a spark of his master’s genius
and without any of his distinction.
THE SCHOOL OF SEVILLE
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account