The common Hawk Cuckoo of India (_Hierococcyx varius_) furnishes an
example of this: “The brain-fever bird,” writes Finn, on page 58 of
_Ornithological and Other Oddities_, “is the most wonderful feather copy
of the Indian Sparrow-hawk or Shikra (_Astur badius_). All the markings
in the hawk are reproduced in the cuckoo, which is also of about the same
size, and of similar proportions in the matter of tail and wing; and both
hawk and cuckoo having a first plumage quite different from the one they
assume when adult, the resemblance extends to that too. Moreover, their
flight is so much the same that unless one is near enough to see the
beak, or can watch the bird settle and note the difference between the
horizontal pose of the cuckoo and the erect bearing of the hawk, it is
impossible to tell them apart on a casual view.” Moreover, the tail of
the cuckoo sometimes hangs down vertically, thus intensifying the
likeness to the hawk.
It is quite possible that the brain-fever bird derives some benefit from
the resemblance; indeed, it has been seen to alarm small birds, even as
the hawk-like common cuckoo frightens its dupes, but, as D. Dewar pointed
out, on page 105 of vol. 57 of the _Journal of the Society of Arts_,
“this is not sufficient to explain a likeness which is so faithful as to
extend to the marking of each individual feather. When a babbler espies a
hawk-like bird, it does not wait to inspect each feather before fleeing
in terror; hence all that is necessary to the cuckoo is that it should
bear a general resemblance to the shikra. The fact that the likeness
extends to minute details in feather marking, points to the fact that in
each case identical causes have operated to produce this type of
plumage.” This conclusion is still further strengthened by the fact that
the likeness extends to the immature plumage, that is to say, exists at a
time when it cannot assist the cuckoo in its parasitical work.
Poulton meets this objection as follows:
[Illustration: SHIKRA HAWK]
[Illustration: HAWK-CUCKOO]
Hypertely
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account