Darwin resorted to much ingenious argument in his attempt to explain what
he believed to be the almost universal sterility of hybrids, as opposed
to mongrels or crosses between varieties. He pointed out that changed
conditions tend to produce sterility, as is evidenced by the fact that
many creatures refuse to breed in confinement, and believed that the
crossing of distinct wild species produced a similar effect on the sexual
organs. He expressed his belief that the early death of the embryos is a
very frequent cause of sterility in first crosses.
Wallace thus summarises Darwin’s conclusions as to the cause of the
sterility of hybrids: “The sterility or infertility of species with each
other, whether manifested in the difficulty of obtaining first crosses
between them or in the sterility of the hybrids thus obtained, is not a
constant or necessary result of species difference, but is incidental on
unknown peculiarities of the reproductive system. These peculiarities
constantly tend to arise under changed conditions owing to the extreme
susceptibility of that system, and they are usually correlated with
variations of form or of colour. Hence, as fixed differences of form and
colour, slowly gained by natural selection in adaptation to changed
conditions, are what essentially characterise distinct species, some
amount of infertility between species is the usual result.”
A Biological Bogey
But Wallace has not been content to let the matter remain where Darwin
left it. He has boldly tried to make an ally of this bogey of the
infertility of hybrids. On page 179 of _Darwinism_ he argues, most
ingeniously, that the sterility of hybrids has been actually produced by
natural selection to prevent the evils of the intercrossing of allied
species. We will not reproduce his argument for the simple reason that it
is now well-known, or should be well-known, that hybrids between allied
species are by no means always sterile. The doctrine of the infertility
of hybrids seems to have been founded on the fact that the hybrids best
known to breeders, namely the cross between the ass and the horse, and
those between the canary and other finches, are sterile.
Fertile Crosses between Species of Plants
In the case of plants the number of fertile hybrids between species is so
large that we cannot attempt to enumerate them. De Vries cites several
instances in Lecture IX of his _Species and Varieties: Their Origin by
Mutation_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account