The man in the street: Papers on American topicsNicholson, Meredith
General
The man in the street: Papers on American topics
Nicholson, Meredith
American essays -- 20th century
Delightful and inspiring as it would doubtless be, we can’t quite
trust the government to the counsels of the ouija-board. The seats
of the cabinet or of the supreme bench will hardly be filled
with table-rapping experts until more of us are satisfied of the
authenticity of the communications that purport to be postmarked
oblivion. We quote the great spirits of the past only when we need
them to give weight and dignity to our own views. (Incidentally, a
ouija-board opinion from John Marshall as to the propriety of tacking
a police regulation like the Eighteenth Amendment to the Federal
Constitution would be first-page stuff for the newspapers.)
Monroe was luckier than most of our patriarchs. The doctrine associated
with his name is jealously treasured by many patriotic Americans who
haven’t the slightest idea of the circumstances that called it forth;
but to mention it in a discussion of international affairs is to stamp
the speaker as a person of breeding, endowed with intellectual gifts of
the highest order. If by some post-mortem referendum we could “call up”
Monroe to explain just how far America might safely go in the defense
of his doctrine, and whether it could be advantageously extended
beyond the baths of all the western stars to keep pace with such an
expansion as that represented by the Philippines, we might profit by
his answer--and again, we might not.
We can’t shirk our responsibilities. One generation can’t do the work
of another. In the last analysis we’ve got to stand on our own feet and
do our own thinking. The Constitution itself has to be interpreted over
and over again, and even amended occasionally; for the world does, in
spite of all efforts to stop it, continue to move right along. This is
not a year in which either of the major parties can safely harp upon
its “traditional policy.” There are skeletons in both closets that
would run like frightened rabbits if dragged into the light and ordered
to solve the riddles of 1920.
The critics of President Wilson have dwelt much on the vision of the
founders, without conceding that he too may be blessed with a seer’s
vision and the tongue of prophecy. To his weaknesses as a leader
I shall revert later; but his high-mindedness and earnest desire
to serve the nation and the world are questioned only by the most
buckramed hostile partisan, or by those who view the present only
through the eyes of dead men.
IV
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account