Lady Kitty had eyes certainly for no one else. When he spoke of "defeating" her, she laughed her defiance, and a glance of battle passed between her and Cliffe. Cliffe, still holding her with his look, considered what new ground to break. "What is the subject?" said Ashe. "That men are vainer than women," said Kitty. "It's so true, it's hardly worth saying--isn't it? Mr. Cliffe talks nonsense about our love of clothes--and of being admired. As if that were vanity! Of course it's only our sense of duty." "Duty?" cried Cliffe, twisting his mustache. "To whom?" "To the men, of course! If we didn't like clothes, if we didn't like being admired--where would you be?" "Personally, I could get on," said Cliffe. "You expect us to be too much on our knees." "As if we should ever get you there if it didn't amuse you!" said Kitty. "Hypocrites! If we don't dress, paint, chatter, and tell lies for you, you won't look at us--and if we do--" "Of course, it all depends on how well it's done," threw in Cliffe. Kitty laughed. "That's judging by results. I look to the motive. I repeat, if I powder and paint, it's not because I'm vain, but because it's my painful duty to give you pleasure." "And if it doesn't give me pleasure?" She shrugged her shoulders. "Call me stupid then--not vain. I ought to have done it better." "In any case," said Ashe, "it's your duty to please us?" "Yes--" sighed Kitty. "Worse luck!" And she sank softly back in her chair, her eyes shining under the stimulus of the laugh that ran through her circle. The Dean joined in it uneasily, conscious, no doubt, of the sharp, crackling movements by which in the distance Lady Grosville was dumbly expressing herself--through the _Times_. Cliffe looked at the small figure a moment, then seized a chair and sat down in front of her, astride. "I wonder why you want to please us?" he said, abruptly, his magnificent blue eyes upon her. "Ah!" said Kitty, throwing up her hands, "if we only knew!" "You find it in the tragedy of your sex?" "Or comedy," said the Dean, rising. "I take you at your word, Lady Kitty. To-night it will be your duty to please _me_. Remember, you promised to say us some more French." He lifted an admonitory finger. "I don't know any 'Athalie,'" said Kitty, demurely, crossing her hands upon her knee. The Dean smiled to himself as he crossed the room to Lady Grosville, and endeavored by an impartial criticism of the new curate's manner and voice, as they had revealed themselves in church that morning, to distract her attention from her niece. A hopeless task--for Kitty's personality was of the kind which absorbs, engulfs attention, do what the by-stander will. Eyes and ears were drawn perforce into the little whirlpool that she made, their owners yielding them, now with delight, now with repulsion.