If we tease the creature, we see welling up from the bottom of these
several little craters an opalescent liquid, which runs and spreads all
over the larva. It has a strong smell of bitter almonds, or rather of
nitrobenzene, commonly known as essence of mirbane, a powerful and most
repulsive smell. The discharge of this substance is a means of defence.
We have only to tickle the insect with a straw or to grip one of its
legs with the tweezers and the eighteen scent-bottles at once begin to
work. Whoso handles the grub will find his fingers stink and will throw
away the noisome perfumer in disgust. If the Chrysomela-larva’s object
in placing nine pairs of nitrobenzene-stills on its back was to repel
man, it has, I admit, thoroughly succeeded.
But man is the least of its enemies. Far more formidable is the
Odynerus, who seizes the scented creature by the skin of the neck and,
despite its sprays of perfume, dispatches it with a few stings. This
was the bandit against whom, above all, it should have defended itself;
and the poor grub has not been happily inspired in this respect.
Considering the huntress’ exclusive taste for this sort of game, we
must presume that the Chrysomela’s drug-shop possesses a delicious
aroma in the Odynerus’ opinion. The defensive secretion becomes a
deadly bait. Even so with other means of protection: each advantage
invariably has some corresponding disadvantage.
I have read, I forget where, the story of certain South-American
Butterflies, some of whom tasted bitter, others not. The first were
respected by the birds because of their bitterness; the second were
eagerly swallowed. What did the persecuted insects do? Unable to
acquire the disagreeable flavour of the bitter ones, they at least
imitated their shape and their costume. And the birds were taken in by
the fraud.
This was put forward as a striking proof of evolution in view of the
struggle for life. I am repeating the story more or less correctly, as
it lingers vaguely in my memory, for I have never attached more
importance than they deserve to pretty inventions of this kind. Is it
really certain that the pungent Butterflies escaped destruction because
of their taste? Might there not be, among the birds, a few passionate
lovers of bitters, to whom the defensive flavour was, on the contrary,
an added lure? My two acres of pebbles tell me nothing of things
Brazilian; nevertheless I learn within their four walls that a grub of
detestable flavour, of the most repulsive aroma, has, like the others,
its appointed consumers and very zealous consumers at that. If the
struggle for life made it acquire its scent-bottles, then the struggle
for life is a fool: it should have left the creature without them. In
this way the enemy most to be feared, the Odynerus, who is attracted by
the smell, would have been avoided.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account