The Master of Man: The Story of a SinCaine, Hall, Sir
General
The Master of Man: The Story of a Sin
Caine, Hall, Sir
Infanticide -- Fiction; Isle of Man -- Fiction; Legal stories; Redemption -- Fiction
"Long ago, in Galilee, out of the supreme compassion which covered
with forgiveness the transgressions of one who had sinned much but
loved much, it was said, 'Let him that is without sin among you cast
the first stone.' We have all done something we would fain forget,
and when we lay our heads on our pillow we pray that the darkness may
hide it. But does anybody doubt that if the all-seeing Justice could
enter this Court this day another figure would be standing there in
the dock by the side of that unhappy woman--a man in scarlet uniform
perhaps, with decorations on his breast, and that the Deemster would
have to say to him, 'You did this, for you were the first.' Mercy,
then--mercy for the beaten, the broken, the scapegoat, the sinner."
People said afterwards that Stowell was a full half minute in his
seat before anybody seemed to be aware that he was no longer speaking.
The spectators had listened without making a sound; the jury (a panel
of stolid Manx farmers) had sat without moving a muscle; the prisoner
had raised her head for the first time during the trial and then
dropped it lower than before and her shoulders had shaken as if from
inaudible sobs; the Governor, who had all day been drawing
geometrical patterns on the sheet of foolscap in front of him, had
let his pencil fall and stared down at the paper, and the Deemster
had looked up at the lantern light from which the sunlight (it had
moved on) was now streaming upon his face, showing at last a solitary
tear that was rolling slowly down his cheek to the end of his
firm-set mouth.
Then there was a rustle, as if the windows of a room on the edge of
the sea had suddenly been thrown open. The Attorney-General was
speaking again. After the defence they had just listened to (there
being no evidence to rebut) he would waive his right of reply--the
Crown desired justice, not revenge.
The Deemster's summing-up was the shortest that had ever been heard
from him. There were legal reasons which justified the taking of
human life, but the cases to which they applied were few. If the
jury thought the prisoner had wilfully killed her husband they would
find her Guilty. If they were satisfied from what they had heard
that she had reasonable grounds for thinking that a felony was being
committed upon her which endangered her own life they would find her
Not Guilty.
Without leaving their box the jury promptly gave a verdict of Not
Guilty; and then the Deemster in a loud, clear, almost triumphant
voice said:
"Let the prisoner be discharged."
A few minutes later there was a scene of excitement on the green
within the Castle walls. The spectators, being turned out of the
Court-house with difficulty, were waiting for the chief actors in the
life-drama to come down the stone steps, and from the private door to
the Deemster's room.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account