The Mathematical Theory of RelativityEddington, Arthur Stanley, Sir
Science
The Mathematical Theory of Relativity
Eddington, Arthur Stanley, Sir
Relativity (Physics)
A possible pitfall in differentiating a summed expression should be noticed.
The result of differentiating $a_{\mu\nu} x_{\mu} x_{\nu}$ with respect to~$x_{\nu}$ is not~$a_{\mu\nu} x_{\mu}$ but
$(a_{\mu\nu} + a_{\nu\mu}) x_{\mu}$. The method of performing such differentiations may be illustrated
by the following example. Let
\[
h_{\nu\tau} = a_{\mu\nu} a_{\sigma\tau} x_{\mu} x_{\sigma},
\]
where $a_{\mu\nu}$~represents constant coefficients. Then
\begin{align*}
\frac{\dd h_{\nu\tau}}{\dd x_{\alpha}}
&= a_{\mu\nu} a_{\sigma\tau} \left(\frac{\dd x_{\mu}}{\dd x_{\alpha}}\, x_{\sigma} + \frac{\dd x_{\sigma}}{\dd x_{\alpha}}\, x_{\mu}\right) \\
&= a_{\mu\nu} a_{\sigma\tau} (g_{\alpha}^{\mu} x_{\sigma} + g_{\alpha}^{\sigma} x_{\mu})
\quad\text{by \Eq{(22.3)}.}
\end{align*}
\PageSep{75}
\index{Differentiation of summed expression}%
Repeating the process,
\begin{align*}
\frac{\dd^{2} h_{\nu\tau}}{\dd x_{\alpha}\, \dd x_{\beta}}
&= a_{\mu\nu} a_{\sigma\tau} (g_{\alpha}^{\mu} g_{\beta}^{\sigma} + g_{\alpha}^{\sigma} g_{\beta}^{\mu}) \\
&= a_{\alpha\nu} a_{\beta\tau} + a_{\beta\nu} a_{\alpha\tau}.
\end{align*}
Hence changing dummy suffixes
\[
\frac{\dd^{2}}{\dd x_{\mu}\, \dd x_{\sigma}} (a_{\mu\nu} a_{\sigma\tau} x_{\mu} x_{\sigma})
= a_{\mu\nu} a_{\sigma\tau} + a_{\sigma\nu} a_{\mu\tau}.
\Tag{(35.5)}
\]
Similarly if $a_{\mu\nu\sigma}$~is symmetrical in its suffixes
\[
\frac{\dd^{3}}{\dd x_{\mu}\, \dd x_{\nu}\, \dd x_{\sigma}} (a_{\mu\nu\sigma} x_{\mu} x_{\nu} x_{\sigma})
= 6a_{\mu\nu\sigma}.
\Tag{(35.6)}
\]
The pitfall arises from repeating a suffix three times in one term. In these
formulae the summation applies to the repetition within the bracket, and not
to the differentiation.
\Subsection{Summary.}
Tensors are quantities obeying certain transformation laws. Their importance
lies in the fact that if a tensor equation is found to hold for one
system of coordinates, it continues to hold when any transformation of
coordinates is made. New tensors are recognised either by investigating
their transformation laws directly or by the property that the sum, difference,
product or quotient of tensors is a tensor. This is a generalisation of the
method of dimensions in physics.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account