The mind of primitive man : $b A course of lectures delivered before the Lowell Institute, Boston, Mass., and the National University of Mexico, 1910-1911Boas, Franz
Science
The mind of primitive man : $b A course of lectures delivered before the Lowell Institute, Boston, Mass., and the National University of Mexico, 1910-1911
Boas, Franz
Ethnopsychology; Race
Even setting aside the strong emotions of modesty, we find a variety of
reasons which make certain styles of dress appear improper. To appear in
the fashion of our forefathers of two centuries ago would be entirely
out of the question, and would expose one to ridicule. To see a man wear
a hat in company indoors nettles us: it is considered rude. To wear a
hat in church or at a funeral would cause more vigorous resentment, on
account of the greater emotional value of the feelings concerned. A
certain tilt of the hat, although it may be very comfortable to the
wearer, would stamp him at once as an uneducated brute. Other novelties
in costume may hurt our æsthetic feelings, no matter how bad the taste
of the prevailing fashions may be.
Another example will make clear what I mean. When we consider our table
manners, it will readily be recognized that most of them are purely
traditional, and cannot be given any adequate explanation. To smack
one’s lips is considered bad style, and may excite feelings of disgust;
while among the Indians it would be considered bad taste not to smack
one’s lips when invited to dinner, because it would suggest that the
guest does not enjoy his meal. Both for the Indian and for ourselves the
constant performance of these actions which constitute good table
manners make it practically impossible to act otherwise. An attempt to
act differently would not only be difficult on account of the lack of
adjustment of muscular motions, but also on account of the strong
emotional resistance that we should have to overcome. The emotional
displeasure is also released when we see others act contrary to custom.
To eat with people having table manners different from our own excites
feelings of displeasure which may rise to such an intensity as to cause
qualmishness. Here, also, explanations are often given which are
probably based solely on attempts to explain the existing manners, but
which do not represent their historical development. We often hear that
it is improper to eat with a knife because it might cut the mouth; but I
doubt very much if this consideration has anything to do with the
development of the custom, for the older type of sharp steel forks might
as easily hurt the mouth as the blade of the knife.
It may be well to exemplify the characteristics of our opposition to
unwonted actions by a few additional examples, which will help to clear
up the mental processes that lead us to formulate the reasons for our
conservatism.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account