Unfortunately, the new physics is difficult, or at least can be made
to seem difficult. Few lay readers have any first-hand knowledge of
it; few lay readers have ever read a book of science in their lives,
new or old. In fact science does not publish itself directly in books,
but in short monographs, editions limited to two or three hundred
copies. At best these papers make their appearance in small, specialist
magazines. And they are couched almost entirely in mathematical symbols
interspersed with long words barbarously derived from the Greek and
Latin. True scientists have not yet learned to advertise.
We are therefore at the mercy of the popularizer, and the popularizer
is under every temptation to bolster up popular prejudices and
misconceptions. There is also the “story interest” which he must
consider.
These are times when government is not by reason, by principle, by
expedience, or by experience. We are governed by story interest--the
thrill such as we get from a good detective yarn. Most of us must get
the bulk of our information from the newspapers, magazines, and the
most accessible and widely distributed of books. These depend upon
story interest for their sales. We buy those periodicals and those
volumes which promise to thrill us most; it is so much more pleasant to
be thrilled than not to be thrilled. Thus it becomes to the interest of
editors to see that we are thrilled as much as possible, without regard
to ultimate consequences. Fiction tends ever more and more to become
the moulder of public opinion.
It is of course a better story if Voronoff’s transplantations of goat
and monkey glands result in prolonged life than if they do not so
result. To say that chemicals will take the place of male sperm in the
fertilization of sea-urchins’ eggs (as Loeb, a few years ago, used to
claim) produces a greater thrill than to say that this consummation so
devoutly wished by some has yet to materialize. It is even thrilling
to be told that life is mechanical, for that gives man the flattering
idea that some day he will be able to create life in his own workshops
and set up an independent business as a god. We do not stop to think
of all the implications of such a theory--and we buy the paper. We go
further, and enact laws which take the truth of the articles in the
paper for granted.
So, when the modern popularizer deigns to give his attention to modern
physics, he has a single eye to the “story.” The difficult parts, the
parts expressing doubt, the parts which do not fit with the pet fads of
his readers, he can omit. Or he can take an entire theory and stand it
on its head. The effect will be exciting--and marvelous.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account