“The prologue of the story of that new religion opens in Galilee.
Almost two thousand years ago there was born in the Galilean village
of Nazareth, a Jewish child to whom was given the name of Joshua, or
Jesus. We do not know for certain how the early years of this child
[Browne adheres to the lower cases in all emergencies] were spent. The
Gospels recount many legends concerning his conception, birth, and
youth, but they are no more to be relied upon than the suspiciously
similar legends told many centuries earlier about Zoroaster.”[162]
The anthropologists were only possibly wrong; but the Gospels recount
legends, and Browne here does not say maybe. Neither does he say where
he gets his information concerning the birthplace of Christ. Had he
ever read even the first Gospel he would have learned that Christ was
born in Bethlehem of Judæa. Perhaps our author referred himself only
to his own stranger-than-fiction history of the Jews.
Anyway, he goes on to declare that this Child “cherished many of the
primitive notions of the simple folk to whom he belonged, believing
that disease and sometimes even death were caused by the presence of
foul demons, and could be removed by prayer. He knew little if any
Greek, and could never have even heard of Greek science or philosophy.
All he knew was the Bible, and probably the text of that had been
taught him only by rote.... Above all he must have been taught to
prize as dearer than life the old obsession of his people that someday
they would be miraculously freed by the Messiah. Indeed, so well was
that last drilled into him that, as he matured, the hunger for the
realization of the hope became his all consuming passion.”[163]
We now have One “who preached only ethics,” and yet cherished an
all-consuming passion for the realization of the obsessive hope of His
people that someday they would be miraculously freed by a Messiah.
If Browne will turn to another book with which he seems to be as
unfamiliar as he is with the Bible, the dictionary, to wit, he will
find ethics defined in some such manner as follows: “Ethics, the
science that treats of the principles of human morality and duty; moral
philosophy; morals.” An obsessive belief in miracles is something quite
beyond ethics, either of a puritanically Jewish or any other variety.
Nor do the cherished primitive notions of simple folk to the effect
that diseases may be cured by prayer savor much of ethics. I do not of
course mean that Christ had no ethics; but Browne has introduced Him
to us as one who preached ethics only. Did He, then, keep his one “all
consuming passion” out of his preaching?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account