As to a touching belief in the efficacy of disease, we may find it in
minds much less confused than Browne’s. It runs through such books as
“The Psychology of Religious Mysticism,” by James H. Leuba, professor
of psychology at Bryn Mawr. According to Browne, mental unbalance
produces indomitable courage and inflexible will. According to
Professor Leuba, the hysterical saints lived lives of “joyful activity,
broken only by transports of surpassing love and peaceful rest.”[187]
Not a very comprehensive description of the lives of saints. But if
there be such hysteria as this, such epilepsy as Browne describes,
it is a pity that the germs cannot be isolated, propagated, and sown
broadcast.
These authors are among those who ruin their hypotheses by
inadvertently accounting for too much. Their hysteria and epilepsy,
stretched to meet all demands, lose the quality of disease and take on
the quality of genius. Would it not be well at least to distinguish two
types of hysteria (some writers make even epilepsy hysterical), the
malignant and the benign? Or if the word hysteria merely means emotion,
why not recognize the fact that an emotion may indicate conditions as
categorically opposite as those reflected in the sensations of pleasure
and of pain? It is grossly irrational to narrow it down to a single
sinister meaning if it is to be put forward as the “cause” and the
“explanation” of such diverse effects as those which are clothed in
the willing garb of a Sister of Charity and those which lead to the
unwilling wearing of a straight-jacket.
Nor is it any less absurd to say that St. Paul, having partaken of
heady salvation-liquor such as was drunken of aforetime only by
charlatans, madmen, arrant knaves and driveling fools, and adding to
its potency by insisting upon its universal applicability--to say all
this even by implication, and then to add as Browne does[188] that “in
his own class, Paul was one of the stupendously great men of the earth.”
“He was,” the narrative continues, “a superb statesman. And he was
possessed of an energy, a courage, and an indomitable will, the like of
which have rarely been known in all the history of great men.... Again
and again he was scourged and imprisoned.... And yet he persisted,
never resting from his grueling labor of carrying his Christ to the
Gentiles, incessantly running to and fro, preaching, writing, arguing
and comforting, until at last, a tired and broken man, he died a
martyr’s death in the city of Rome.... It was in the year 67, according
to tradition, that Paul was beheaded.”
Once again Browne considers himself privileged to repudiate all that
a man stands for, his sole claim to distinction, and yet to put him
on a pedestal of insincere rhetoric. When he speaks of Paul’s “own
class” does he mean the class of “charlatans, madmen, arrant knaves and
driveling fools”? Indeed, St. Paul himself is reported to have said,
“If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most
miserable.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account