The Modes of Ancient Greek MusicMonro, D. B. (David Binning)
History
The Modes of Ancient Greek Music
Monro, D. B. (David Binning)
Music, Greek and Roman
With regard to the place of origin of the notation the chief fact
which we have to deal with is the use of the character [Symbols: I-]
for lambda, which is distinctive of the alphabet of Argos, along with
the commoner form [Symbols: <]. Westphal indeed asserts that both
these forms are found in the Argive alphabet. But the inscription (C.
I. 1) which he quotes[1] for [Symbols: <] really contains only
[Symbols: t-] in a slightly different form. We cannot therefore say
that the inventor of the notation derived it entirely from the
alphabet of Argos, but only that he shows an acquaintance with that
alphabet. This is confirmed by the fact that the form [Symbols: Li]
for iota is not found at Argos. Probably therefore the inventor drew
upon more than one alphabet for his purpose, the Argive alphabet
being one.
[Footnote 1: _Harmonik und Melopöie_, p. 286 (ed. 1863). The true
form of the letter is given by Mr. Roberts, _Greek Epigraphy_, p.
109.]
The special fitness of the notation for the scales of the Enharmonic
genus may be regarded as a further indication of its date. We shall
see presently that that genus held a peculiar predominance in the
earliest period of musical theory--that, namely, which was brought to
an end by Aristoxenus.
If the author of the notation--or the second author, inventor of the
modified characters--was one of the musicians whose names have come
down to us, it would be difficult to find a more probable one than
that of Pronomus of Thebes. One of the most striking features of the
notation, at the time when it was framed, must have been the
adjustment of the keys. Even in the time of Aristoxenus, as we know
from the passage so often quoted, that adjustment was not universal.
But it is precisely what Pronomus of Thebes is said to have done for
the music of the flute (_supra_, p. 38). The circumstance that the
system was only used for instrumental music is at least in harmony
with this conjecture. If it is thought that Thebes is too far from
Argos, we may fall back upon the notice that Sacadas of Argos was the
chief composer for the flute before the time of Pronomus[1], and
doubtless Argos was one of the first cities to share in the advance
which Pronomus made in the technique of his art.
[Footnote 1: Pausanias (iv. 27, 4) says of the founding of Messene:
[Greek: eirgazonto de kai hypo mousuiês allês men oudemias, aulôn de
Boiôtiôn kai Argeiôn; ta te Sakada kai Pronomou melê tote dê
proêchthê malista eis hamillan.]]
§ 28. _Traces of the Species in the Notation._
Before leaving this part of the subject it will be well to notice the
attempt which Westphal makes to connect the species of the Octave
with the form of the musical notation.
The basis of the notation, as has been explained (p. 69), is formed
by two Diatonic octaves, denoted by the letters of the alphabet from
[Greek: a] to [Greek: n], as follows:
[Greek: ê i e l g m [digamma] th k d l b n z a]
_ a b c d e f g a b c d e f g a_
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account