The modes of origin of lowest organisms: including a discussion of the experiments of M. PasteurBastian, H. Charlton
History
The modes of origin of lowest organisms: including a discussion of the experiments of M. Pasteur
Bastian, H. Charlton
Life -- Origin; Spontaneous generation
*No. LXIV.* " " " 167° F.
*No. LXV.* " " " 167° F.
All these solutions remained quite clear and free from any trace
of general turbidity for ten days. Each fluid was then inoculated
with some living _Bacteria_, and in the space of thirty-six to
seventy-two hours, all had become more or less obviously turbid, and on
microscopical examination this turbidity was found in each case to be
almost wholly due to the presence of multitudes of _Bacteria_.
_Interpretation of the Experiments: Conclusions as to the Cause of
Fermentation, and as to the Occurrence of_ *Archebiosis*.
These experiments seem to show quite conclusively that M. Pasteur’s
explanations are altogether inadequate to account for the occasional
preservation of boiled fluids in bent-neck flasks. They show that the
preservation, far from being universal, is only occasional, and that
preservation or non-preservation of different fluids is almost wholly
dependent upon their nature. They lend no countenance, moreover, to his
particular theory, that fermentation cannot be initiated without the
agency of living ferments,--they are, on the contrary, wholly opposed
to this restriction.
The plug of cotton-wool, or the narrow and bent tube may, it is
true, protect the boiled fluid from subsequent contact with living
“germs”; but that the fluids do not undergo change on account of such
deprivation cannot be safely affirmed, when the same means would also
filter from the fluid some of the multitudinous particles of organic
matter (dead), which the air undoubtedly contains, and which may
act as ferments. It must be remembered that the main object of M.
Pasteur’s investigation was to determine whether fermentation took
place under the agency of mere dead nitrogenous matter, as Liebig and
others affirm; or whether it is only initiated by living organisms, as
he himself supposes. Obviously, therefore, the same filtration which
purified the air from any living organisms would filter from it its
nitrogenous particles, which are the other possible ferments: so that
no conclusion could be drawn from such experiments, more favourable
to the one than to the other of these hypotheses. All that could
have been safely affirmed was, that by boiling the fluid, and then
protecting it from subsequent contact with everything that could act as
a ferment, fermentation would not take place.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account