The modes of origin of lowest organisms: including a discussion of the experiments of M. PasteurBastian, H. Charlton
History
The modes of origin of lowest organisms: including a discussion of the experiments of M. Pasteur
Bastian, H. Charlton
Life -- Origin; Spontaneous generation
The views hitherto expressed with reference to the causes of
fermentation and putrefaction, and to the interpretations which M.
Pasteur’s experiments are capable of receiving, seem to derive all
the additional support that can be needed, from the results of my own
experiments with boiled fluids, in sealed flasks, from which all air
had been expelled.
Some of the same fluid being taken and divided into three parts, each
portion is placed in a separate flask, in which it is boiled for a
period of ten minutes. One of the flasks (A) is provided with a long
and bent neck, so that the air which re-enters is deprived of its germs
and organic particles; another (B) has only a short neck, and to this,
the access of germs and organic particles is freely permitted till the
fluid has become cool, and then the neck of the flask is hermetically
sealed; whilst the last (C) is sealed during ebullition, after all air
has been expelled. Now, if Pasteur’s theory of fermentation, and the
prevalent notions concerning the universal distribution of “germs”
throughout the atmosphere were true, it might be expected that the
fluid in B would always rapidly change; that that in A would always
remain pure; and that the fluid in C would, similarly, undergo no
alteration. The facts, however, are quite the reverse: if a strong
turnip infusion be employed, the fluid in A will almost always remain
unchanged; that in B will sometimes rapidly change, and at other
times will remain quite pure; whilst that in C will almost invariably
become turbid in from two to six days. But, even if it were not the
case that some fluids, different from those used by M. Pasteur, will
almost invariably undergo change in bent-neck vessels, M. Pasteur’s
explanation of the cause of the preservation would have been altogether
upset by the fact that _some of the very fluids which remain pure in
the bent-neck apparatus will become fœtid if shut up in vacuo_. It
is, therefore, of course useless to talk of a particular boiled fluid
having been saved from putrefaction on the ground that the living
atmospheric germs (whose presence is supposed to be necessary for the
initiation of such a process) have been altogether filtered from the
re-entering air, when some of the same fluid will putrefy, if placed
under different conditions by which it is freed both from the influence
of the atmosphere and from its germs--_i.e._, when, instead of
filtering the re-entering air, no air is permitted to enter. Germs and
atmospheric particles being equally got rid of in both sets of cases,
the great difference between them is that the weight of the atmosphere
is also got rid of in my experiments--the fluids being contained
_in vacuo_. Now it has been ascertained by Mr. Sorby, that pressure
undoubtedly influences “chemical changes taking place slowly, and
therefore, probably due to weak or nearly counterbalanced affinities;”
and he also states, in the Bakerian Lecture for 1863,[84] that “a
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account