The Monist, Vol. 2, 1891-1892 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 2, 1891-1892 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
The law of the conservation of matter and energy is nothing but an
application of the principle of identity to nature as a whole. And the
law of cause and effect is again a corollary only of the law of the
conservation of matter and energy. The law of causation is a formula
which maintains that there is identity in difference. Some motion
produces a change of form. There is accordingly a different state after
the motion than before. Yet the total amount of matter and energy
remains the same. This is the identity in the change. David Hume and
with him John Stuart Mill and the empiricists misunderstood the problem
of causation. Instead of considering cause and effect as one continuous
process that should be analysed, they considered cause and effect
separately and attempted a synthesis. In addition to this mistake, causes
as well as effects were defined to be objects. Hume says cause and
effect are objects following one another. Cause however is a process;
it is a motion, a change that takes place, an event that happens; it
is not a thing. And effect is the product of such a process. Effect is
a special form, a special state of things, a special configuration,
but not the material of which this configuration consists. A certain
poison introduced into the stomach of a living being produces certain
motions in the bowels, called cramps, which may finally prove fatal.
One change produces other changes and their product is a new state of
things which is accompanied with pain and ends in death. It is wrong to
call strychnine the cause and a dead mouse the effect. But if we call
strychnine the cause and a dead mouse the effect, we must forever despair
of solving the problem of causation by a reduction to the principle of
identity, for strychnine is not at all identical with a dead mouse. No
cause is the same thing as its effect, and we can by no means identify
cause and effect. And yet the principle of identity holds good. The
identity in causation is the conservation of matter and energy in a
change of form.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account