The Monist, Vol. 2, 1891-1892 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 2, 1891-1892 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
However, whether we use the term “ego” in the sense of the idea “I”
meaning the whole personality of the speaker, or in the sense of the
present centre of consciousness, it designates in either case a definite
reality, the origin and action of which are natural facts and as plain as
any other psychological phenomena.
Neither the ego-idea nor the centre of consciousness are transcendental.
The former is as little mystical as are the ideas dog, horse, man, etc.;
the latter no less miraculous than any other feeling or display of
sentiency.
VIII. THE EGO-CENTRIC VIEW ABANDONED.
The contrast between the old and the new psychology appears strongest
in their conceptions of the ego. The former believes that the ego is
“the thing in itself” of man’s soul and takes it to be the centre of
all psychical phenomena, while the latter looks upon the ego-idea as
one idea among many other co-ordinated ideas and considers the centre
of consciousness as the strongest feeling at a given time, which as
such naturally predominates over and eclipses the other feelings of the
organism.
The new psychology brings about a change of standpoint similar to
that effected by the Copernican system in astronomy. In astronomy
the geo-centric, and in psychology the ego-centric standpoint had to
be abandoned. And all things seem to be upset to those who are still
accustomed to the old conception. To them the physical and moral
world-conceptions appear to become impossible. If the new view were
correct, so they imagine, the entire universe would break to pieces. All
our modes of speech are formed in accord with the old view. We speak of
sunset and sunrise, and so in our daily conversation the little pronoun
“I” plays a part which makes it seem as if the ego-idea were the centre
of all soul-life and as if this “I” were the active agent in all acts of
willing and doing.
The advantage of the Copernican system lies in this, that we can think
of the motions of the sun and the planets in a systematic and unitary
conception without being either involved in contradictions or obliged to
invent mysterious qualities in the stars for explaining the velocities,
directions, or other phenomena of the celestial bodies. The most
important advantage however is the practical applicability of the new
theory.
The old theory of the soul necessarily leads to mysticism. Fictitious
facts of a transcendent character must be invented in addition to the
facts observed, in order to explain the latter. The new theory after
abandoning the ego-centric standpoint of the thing in itself of a soul
shows the facts of psychic life in an harmonious and unitary conception.
All facts agree among themselves and we are not in need of supplementing
them with mysterious inventions. It must be emphasised, at the same time,
that the new conception throws a new light upon ethics; it shows the
error and perversity of all egotism, for it would be a mistake to act as
if the ego were really the centre of soul-life.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account