The Monist, Vol. 2, 1891-1892 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 2, 1891-1892 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
“The question is, (1) Are there psychological processes in us, the
development of which presents itself with immediate certainty as
necessary, and (2) can we reduce all the individual and with them all the
spiritual phenomena to such spiritual processes recognised as necessary?
The first question can be affirmed, although only in a limited sense,
and the second question must be unequivocally denied, thus making an
immediate explanation of psychical phenomena impossible” (p. 107).
The first question is to be affirmed in a limited sense, because “if
certain premises are thought, the conclusion, it appears to us as a
necessity, can be thought thus and not otherwise” (p. 108). But this
is “a logical and not a psychological necessity.” To actually think
the conclusion depends upon the will to think it. The will actually
existing, the logical necessity becomes a psychological, for “the
connection between the willing and the willed (_zwischen Willen und
Gewolltem_) always appears to us as necessary.... Where there is inner
will there is an inner necessity.” Now, in order to make explanations in
the physical world, we supplement that which has been actually observed
with not-observed connections. But we cannot, according to Münsterberg,
in an analogous way supplement in the world of psychical phenomena the
conscious states with any other kind of states which are not conscious,
thus referring our spiritual life and acts of will to unconscious
processes, for “the very nature of psychical states is consciousness,
i. e. a state of being conscious. _Ihr Sein ist das bewusst-sein...._
A state of consciousness, says Münsterberg, which is not conscious,
is comparable not to a body which is not perceived, but to one which
does not exist. Accordingly unconscious psychical phenomena do not
exist. All psychical phenomena are directly given and the reduction of
their combinations in a certain way through hypothetical psychological
supplements is once for all excluded” (p. 110).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account