The Monist, Vol. 2, 1891-1892 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 2, 1891-1892 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
The fundamental thesis of the present work is that the three
contemporaneous philosophic systems, those of Criticism, Positivism,
and Evolutionism, are merely varieties of a single species, as strictly
parallel manifestations of a common stock of beliefs and general
hypotheses. The basic identity of the thought of this century is shown
by the ever increasing convergence of the great leading ideas, as
exhibited in the prevailing theories of knowledge, by the preponderance
of relativism, and of agnosticism. It reveals itself, especially in the
similar conceptions formed by the most varied systems, not only of the
essential characters of philosophy, its method, and the ends it ought to
pursue, but also of the scientific laws which govern its evolution. We
cannot follow the author through his discussion of all these points and
we must therefore restrict ourselves to the most salient features of his
argument.
Modern philosophy is represented by three principal schools: Criticism
which originated with Kant, Positivism founded by Comte, and Evolutionism
introduced by Spencer. These three systems had a common ancestry,
that of sensualism. The critical philosophy is the legitimate heir of
sensuous idealism, and the positive philosophy the immediate descendant
of sensuous materialism. The evolution philosophy is itself rooted in
sensualism, but it is really a conciliator of the two great philosophies
which preceded it, Criticism and Positivism. This conclusion, which
appears to us just, is supported by various considerations to which
reference here is not necessary. M. de Roberty bears testimony to
the influence of the philosophy of Kant over the development of the
evolutionist conception, which could be applied to society only by
giving an apparent universality to the mechanical hypothesis. This was
accomplished by Spencer, as it had been done to some extent by Comte.
The popularity of the evolution philosophy is explained by the author
as due to its admixture of agnosticism with a monism which captivates
the masses “by the audacious assertion that it has raised all veils and
resolved all enigmas.” Kant, Comte, and Spencer have equally seized this
characteristic trait of the genius of our century. They each treat, says
M. de Roberty, of the most transcendent problems of metaphysics, and
place them carefully under the cover of the experimental method. Let us
add that they are each different expressions of that genius, which marks
the progress of the mental evolution of mankind.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account