The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
of other physical characters; the theory and explanation of intellectual
operations, of feelings and volitions, belong to the special physiology
of man and to the application of the ideas of general physiology.”
While accepting as correct the division of anthropology, in its
restricted sense into general and special, as proposed by Broca and
Bertillon, the author thinks it does not conform to the plan which
should be adopted if it is desired to proceed, by the method of analysis
and synthesis, from the known to the unknown. The plan adopted by Dr.
Topinard is, by analogy with the procedures of general zoölogy, to
begin by recalling the general notions applicable to his subject as to
the distribution of animals by groups of varying values, the choice
of characters on which they repose, and the differences between the
race, the species, the family, and the order, these last forming the
pivoting point of his views as to the place of man in classification.
Then commences the study of characteristics, the mode of ascertaining
them, of putting them to use and of appreciating their value, accompanied
by examples, drawn from special anthropology, proper to illustrate the
methods employed. Finally, a parallel is drawn between man and animals,
that a conclusion may be arrived at as to the place of man in the series
of beings, and his probable genealogy.
All these points are carefully considered by the author, who has framed
a canon of the medium adult man of the European type, a figure based
on which forms the frontispiece to the work. The proportions of this
figure are derived from a comparison of all the most authentic published
measurements, and the canon framed from them conforms closely to that
recognised in artists’ studios, except that in the latter the arm is too
short and the neck too long.
The most generally interesting subjects discussed by the author are
those connected with the relationship of man to other animals, and
particularly the structure of the brain. Dr. Topinard makes a careful
comparison of the cerebral convolutions of various animals and man,
with numerous illustrations, and he arrives at the conclusion that none
of the characters said to distinguish man from the anthropoid apes are
absolute; all are reducible to a question of degree of evolution, the
superior degree being sometimes found among the anthropoids, and the
inferior degree with man. The cerebral type of the anthropoids is a human
type not completely developed, or the cerebral type of man is a developed
simian type. Man thus undoubtedly belongs to the order of the Primates.
After considering the form and volume of the simian and human brains,
the author remarks that “man alone has a frontal lobe developed in all
its parts, and filling up a large, concave, and deep frontal shell which
externally gives place to the forehead, one of the characteristics of
man.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account