The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
Now it is very possible that a greater _number_ of the actions of women
have their ground in unconscious causes than of the actions of men.
The subjects upon which action is of vital concern to them have been
different subjects, and hence their stored-up stock of knowledge is
knowledge about different subjects. To the woman of the past, who was to
a great extent confined to her own home, the temper of her house-mates
was what her happiness depended upon more than anything else in the
world. It was impossible that she should not acquire a keen intelligence
in interpreting every slightest shade of expression upon the human face.
But this sort of knowledge is always instinctive, whether it is practised
by men or by women. If the eyes of the most reasonable man in the world
should chance to show him a certain curve of the lip and a certain
elevation of the posterior angle of the alæ of the nostrils on the face
of the fair lady to whom he was talking, would he try to call to mind the
pictures in Sir Charles Bell’s great work on expression and the general
theorems in Darwin’s book on the same subject, and piecing this and that
laboriously together, would he try to arrive at some just conclusion
regarding the contents of the fair lady’s mind? Would he not, rather,
instinctively change the subject of conversation, or even discreetly
beat a retreat, long before he had time to _think_? Women’s interests
have been so exclusively social that they have developed a sense for the
physical expression of emotion which makes society for them a matter of
complicated relations, of delicate susceptibility to play of feeling,
which—except in the hyper-sensitive period of courtship—is not common
among men. But there are men who are quite the equals of women in this
respect; and if any man is markedly deficient in these qualities, we
recognise him as belonging to a low and brutal type which is in process
of extinction. If a woman on the other hand, goes into business, she does
not fix the prices of her straw hats each morning in accordance with the
feelings which straw hats awaken in her when she first looks at them,
but in accordance with the fluctuations of the market. The President of
a New Hampshire Street Railway did not carry through her improvements by
her intuitions, but by a plain, common-sense weighing of reasons. Nor are
all masculine occupations under the guidance of the reasoning faculty. If
you go to a stove-man and ask him to mend your smoking chimney, does he
do it by reason? Not a bit of it! There may be stove-men who have enough
knowledge of the laws which regulate the movements of masses of hot air
to be able to apply general principles to particular instances, but in
the course of a long and checkered experience with stove-men, it has not
been my lot to fall in with them. Their knowledge of chimneys, such as it
is, is got by experience and applied by intuition, and nothing is farther
from their minds than any trace of deductive reasoning.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account