The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
The subject is a vast one; one could include in it aphasia and all the
weaknesses resulting from the destruction of the brain-centres, whether
those of motion or of sensation. M. Sollier has taken the pains to reduce
it, however, to definite limits. He studies especially the subject of
acquired amnesia (diminutive changes and disaggregations of the memory).
He does not consider the subject of congenital amnesia, which is an
absence and not a loss of memory. Strictly considered, the only cases
of true amnesia, or _organic_ amnesia, are those which result from the
destruction of the nerve-centres, since in this case there is an absolute
loss of the power of forming mental images, and not simply an enfeebling
or forgetting of them, which is characteristic of _functional_ amnesia.
From a clinical standpoint amnesia exists only in the last case. Though
the effect may be the same in both cases, the causes are not identical.
Clinical investigation cannot, however, overlook the diminutive changes
which take place in the memory and which, as early as 1817, were called
by Louyer-Villermay dysmnesia, and which are always closely allied
to organic modifications of the brain. As regards amnesia itself, it
is important to distinguish simple amnesia from retrogressive and
progressive amnesia. M. Sollier explains the motive causes of these
different conditions with great lucidity, and renders them easy of
comprehension by means of ingenious illustrations.
I call attention to the information he gives us as to the conditions
under which a revival of mental images takes place, p. 30; to his
criticism of Ribot’s opinion, according to which the power of correctly
locating events in the scale of time is the true characteristic of
psychical memory: it is quite enough if it reproduces events as in
the past, that is to say if there exists a conscious knowledge which
shows that the mental conception belongs to the past, or is, simply, a
remembrance, p. 35 and 40; to his remarks on the strengthening of mental
images due to the repetition of remembrances, the necessary sequence of
which is that a weakening of old memories follows the destruction of
accumulated mental images, p. 48; to his explanation of the processes
of retrogressive amnesia (coming suddenly after an attack of vertigo,
a blow, etc.) which he bases upon a supposition of a group of mental
conceptions in touch with one another, in such a way that the loss of
one leading conception in a group deprives this group of sufficient
consistency to form a conscious synthesis, p. 70.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account