The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
Spontaneous is derived from the Latin _spons_, “will,” which as a noun
was obsolete at the classical period of Roman literature and occurred
only in such forms as _sponte_, “of one’s own will, of one’s own accord.”
If a man acts of his own will, free from and not biassed by the influence
of other men, his action is spontaneous. A free man’s action is not
arbitrary, unless arbitrariness[15] be the character of the man; it is
not an exception to law; it is, if the character of the man is known,
calculable in advance, for every free action is spontaneous: it springs
immediately from the character of the man; it is the direct expression of
his will; it reveals the nature of his very being, thus showing the man
himself, and not something beyond or outside of him.
Taking the word spontaneity in this sense, we say: Masses gravitate
spontaneously; they are self-moving; their motion is due to their
gravity, and gravity is their intrinsic nature.
Exactly as the laws of mechanics explain the “how” of motions but not
why there is motion at all, the “why” depending upon the nature of
each moving body, so the “how” of the brain-motions is explicable by
mechanical laws, but the “why” depends upon the nature of the moving
material. The brain-atoms are possessed of the same spontaneity as the
atoms of a gravitating stone. Yet there is present an additional feature;
there are present states of awareness, and these states of awareness
possess meaning, both of which are items which the chemist cannot find
by chemical analysis. Neither states of awareness nor their meanings
can be weighed on any scales, be they ever so delicate, nor are they
determinable in foot-pounds.
Yet while mechanics is not applicable to mental facts, the realm of
mentality is by no means to be surrendered to indeterminism. Mr. Peirce
describes the domain of mind as the absence of law and the prevalence of
absolute chance, of an indetermined and indeterminable sporting. This is
not so. While the fact must be recognised that the nature of the mind
is not something mechanical, its action is nevertheless determined by
laws—not by mechanical laws, but by psychical and mental laws. These
psychical and mental laws are in one respect of exactly the same nature
as mechanical laws; they describe the samenesses of certain facts of
reality. And the facts of the ideal domain of thought, the facts of
subjectivity, are no less real than the grosser facts of mechanical
motion, which are the facts of objectivity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account