The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
It is easy to perceive that these views, if they could be maintained,
would completely transform the Darwinian theory. Since, if the somatic
cells, that is, the body-parts of animals and plants, with all their
adaptations to soil and climate, to definite modes of life, etc., are
to be deprived of every power to transmit hereditary characters, then
the so-called Lamarckian theory, which should really bear the name of
Erasmus Darwin, would be deprived of every foundation which it possesses.
Neither the increase in strength of the members of the body, acquired
by use and practice, nor their weakness created by their non-use could
be inherited; and in just as small a degree could changes caused by
external influences, bodily injuries, sickness, entail consequences which
were inheritable. This being the case, then also all those views would
be untenable which seek to explain the important effects of time as the
result of the accumulation and augmentation of the minute impressions of
the external environment. If the variations which are generated by means
of external influences are not capable of transmission, then the direct
adaptation must commence at the beginning in the case of every following
generation; an accumulation is impossible.
We can observe, however, in every particular case, the complete harmony
in which every living being exists with its surroundings and mode of
life; and observe in closely related species the most various adaptations
to the elements in which they live: climate, food, nay, even to the
particular companions with which they associate; with the result that
many plants have shaped the structure of their flowers to conform to
the physical anatomy of the insect which ordinarily effects their
fertilisation, and that animals assume the figure and form of some
associate who is safe from hostile assaults, or even completely adopt
different modes of life where it is necessary to enter a life-partnership
with a strange animal or plant. But, granting that the most widely
extended capability of adaptation is a thing of daily experience, there
still arises the question how we shall explain this quality, which can
only be brought about by slow degrees, without taking into account the
factor of heredity in the transmission of acquired qualities. The theory
of Weismann attempts this, in that it takes for granted an infinite
variability in the germ-formative materials, and guides the new forms and
variations thus begotten into the really true path, that is, into the
most successful paths, through the process of natural selection (that
is, through the survival of the fittest as regards environment and all
other things). According to this doctrine, external circumstances have
no direct influence whatever upon the variation of species, as Erasmus
Darwin, Lamarck, and the founder of the theory of natural selection and
all his followers up to that time supposed, but we have to have recourse
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account