There are just two ways in which those designated as the “lower
classes” might become the means of our undoing: Some of “the interests”
which have respectable standing might persuade, deceive, wheedle,
or inflame them into the support of some evil that they could not
originate; or, long-continued injustice and repression might lead to an
explosion. No significant explosion of the classes in question will be
brought about in any other way. In other words, what makes the “lower
classes” dangerous, as far as they are dangerous, is the respectable
classes.
The depravity of our respectable thinking upon social and political
interests shows itself, thus, in the actual (though, of course,
unintended) meanness of blaming others where we ourselves deserve
the blame, and even of attributing to others the evils that we cause
through them when we use them for our own ends.
5--Nothing is more characteristic of respectability than its habit
of finding exalted reasons for justifying conventional conduct,
whatever it is. High ground for our conventional domestic conduct is
found in the unalterable nature of the sexes, or in a trust committed
by society, or in some ancient scripture. Reason for unlimited
profit-getting is found by manufacturing psychology to order (the
pseudo-psychology of the motives for enterprise), and in the old,
comfortable middle-class self-sophistication that asserts that private
selfishness is the best way to serve the common good. In ecclesiastical
matters we have been much pushed in later years to find divinely good
reasons for our customary conformities, such as saying in worship what
we do not mean; keeping straight faces in the presence of small men
arrayed in large historical and institutional dignities; supporting a
denominationalism that we say we deplore, and excusing an evangelism
that obviously needs an explanation. We are put to it to place all
these things within a system of rational thought, but we manage
to do it, though it takes some culture to accomplish the feat. In
education--I speak from the inside--it is positively funny how many
old and creaky things, and how few new things can be justified by mere
guesses.
This respectable habit of finding that we always are in every respect
respectable makes it next to impossible for us to repent for even the
deeper wrongs of conventional social practice. Even the harlots, Jesus
declared, enter the Kingdom of Heaven before those who could give
twenty reasons why harlots cannot get in at all.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account