It is an interesting coincidence that the concept of organism should
emerge in physics and the concept of configuration in psychology almost
simultaneously. As far as I am aware, there has been no connection
or interdependence between them. It is even more interesting that
both concepts should spring directly from experimentation. Much more
experimental research must be made before we shall definitely know
just what truth there is in the _Gestalt_-psychology, and just how the
concept of “configuration” applies, if it applies at all, at different
levels of conduct. Prediction is precarious, and it is uncalled
for; but again it lies upon the surface that here is a movement,
experimental in method, that is destined, if it goes on, to instate the
self as an actual determiner and organizer of behavior at the levels
usually called social and ethical. And the self will not only not be
conceived as an aggregate (even of forces); it will not be construed
primarily by its antecedents of whatever sort. Adjustment, that is,
will not be conceived as accommodation of a given organism to a given
environment merely, but as also re-creation of both organism and
environment. An entirely reasonable attitude might then be expressed as
follows: “This is the sort of self, and this is the sort of society,
that we want to be; let us, then, create educational, physiological,
and economic conditions favorable thereto.”
The position of psychoanalysis in the total movement of psychology is
somewhat ambiguous, or at least not well worked out. On the one hand,
we have here a genuine attempt at a dynamic psychology. The object
under contemplation is not the brain; it is scarcely psycho-physical;
it is predominantly, almost exclusively, mental, and the mental is
conceived of not as a perceiving, knowledge-getting function, but as
overwhelmingly desire--designing, scheme-forming, outward-pressing
desire. Further, the individual is treated predominantly as an
individual rather than as an aggregate. The disorders of personality
are the main interest, and the treatment of these disorders is directed
toward a reorganization of the personality so that it shall function as
a unit. On the other hand, the raw material of human nature appears
to be much like a congeries of instincts, or a collection of wild
animals each of which is ready to spring into action upon the slightest
occasion. The endeavor to discover some central desire that uses these
instincts for its own purposes is, indeed, a movement towards an
organic view of the individual; but even the central desire, in the
absence of help from the psychoanalyst, seems to have a substantially
wild, instinctive quality.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account