The Natural Food of Man: Being an attempt to prove from comparative anatomy, physiology, chemistry and hygiene, that the original, best and natural diet of man is fruit and nutsCarrington, Hereward
Science
The Natural Food of Man: Being an attempt to prove from comparative anatomy, physiology, chemistry and hygiene, that the original, best and natural diet of man is fruit and nuts
Carrington, Hereward
Food; Vegetarianism
vegetable elements, will resist this decomposing action for a much
larger period, yet it will in the end putrefy with all the phenomena
of that formed from flesh meat.”
The bearing of these facts on physical training, the health of the
body, and the decomposition of the body after death, need only be
pointed out.
It is really extraordinary how writers on dietetics, seem to
take a delight, as a rule, in making as many mis-statements and
misrepresentations as possible. Take, for example, the following
passage in Dr C. S. Read’s Book, “Fads and Feeding”:—
“It is necessary, with the vegetable products, to take the nitrogenous
product as Nature gives it to us, which is a drawback; and secondly,
vegetable foods are relatively much poorer in this respect than
animal foods.... A vegetable diet must needs be bulky, because of
its wateriness, especially when cooked, and the large amount of
indigestible matter it contains. This tends to abnormally distend
the stomach and bowels. The capacity of the stomach becomes greater,
more food can be taken, but the distention produces a feeling of
satiety before sufficient nourishment has really been ingested. The
dealing with such a bulk internally means the expenditure of much
nervous energy which might have been better utilised. The wateriness
of vegetable foods is extremely disadvantageous, since on absorption
it tends to render all the tissues flabby. The individual who leads a
sedentary life will feel the disadvantage of vegetarianism more than
the active worker.”
Now, not a sentence in the above quotation is correct. If Dr Read
had studied vegetarians at first hand, he would have found out his
mistakes, and would not have written such rubbish. As a matter of
fact, vegetable foods _do not_ supply less nitrogen than meat, but on
the contrary more; a vegetable diet _need not_ be bulky, if properly
selected—_less_ of it need be eaten than of a mixed diet, because of
its greater nutritive value; while the notion that the absorbtion
of water from the foods make the tissues “flabby” is, of course,
absurd. Altogether, this is almost the greatest string of inaccuracies
regarding diet that I have ever come across.
There is one aspect of this question which it might be well to touch
upon in this place. The air that we breathe, as we know, contains
a large percentage of nitrogen. Might it not be possible for the
system to utilise some of this nitrogen, when the body is in a state
of nitrogen starvation? Dr De Lacy Evans, surgeon to St Saviour’s
Hospital, in London, contended that this might be the case, and in his
“How to Prolong Life,” pp. 76-80, wrote:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account