The nature of the physical worldEddington, Arthur Stanley, Sir
Philosophy
The nature of the physical world
Eddington, Arthur Stanley, Sir
Physics -- Philosophy; Science -- Philosophy
Infinite space cannot be conceived by anybody; finite but unbounded
space is difficult to conceive but not impossible. I shall not expect
you to conceive it; but you can try. Think first of a circle; or,
rather, not the circle, but the line forming its circumference. This
[Pg 81]
is a finite but endless line. Next think of a sphere—the surface of
a sphere—that also is a region which is finite but unbounded. The
surface of this earth never comes to a boundary; there is always some
country beyond the point you have reached; all the same there is not
an infinite amount of room on the earth. Now go one dimension more;
circle, sphere—the next thing. Got that? Now for the real difficulty.
Keep a tight hold of the skin of this hypersphere and imagine that the
inside is not there at all—that the skin exists without the inside.
That is finite but unbounded space.
No; I don’t think you have quite kept hold of the conception. You
overbalanced just at the end. It was not the adding of one more
dimension that was the real difficulty; it was the final taking away
of a dimension that did it. I will tell you what is stopping you. You
are using a conception of space which must have originated many million
years ago and has become rather firmly embedded in human thought.
But the space of physics ought not to be dominated by this creation
of the dawning mind of an enterprising ape. Space is not necessarily
like this conception; it is like—whatever we find from experiment it
is like. Now the features of space which we discover by experiment
are extensions, i.e. lengths and distances. So space is like a
network of distances. Distances are linkages whose intrinsic nature
is inscrutable; we do not deny the inscrutability when we apply
measure numbers to them—2 yards, 5 miles, etc.—as a kind of code
distinction. We cannot predict out of our inner consciousness the laws
by which code-numbers are distributed among the different linkages
of the network, any more than we can predict how the code-numbers
for electromagnetic force are distributed. Both are a matter for
[Pg 82]
experiment.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account