The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
History
The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
Home rule -- Ireland; Ireland -- Politics and government
questions from a different angle. Its emphasis is different, its
essentials are trifles to other people, and their essentials are its
trifles. Its problems, even when on the surface they appear the same, have
a different historic background, are interwoven with special associations,
complicated with local and peculiar sympathies and animosities. With these
nuances the smaller nation can never hope that the majority will deal,
because the majority can never understand them. Not only so but the
smaller people will have a pride, memory, and hope of its own. It may have
a larger patriotism if its self respect is first consulted, but as long as
its independent being is ignored its only collective ambition will be to
assert itself. Thus in the subject people the milk of social feeling is
turned to gall. All that leads a free people to respect law, to support
Government, to take pride in public prosperity, to sacrifice personal to
common interest, will work in this case only towards discord and civil
strife, and the best men become in a sense the worst citizens. At least
they become the most resolute opponents of the established order. The more
opposition develops, and this means the more life flourishes in the
subject people, the more the tension increases. Presently definite
obstructions arise in the machinery of Government and the ruling
democracy, however liberal in its original intentions, is driven into
“exceptional” legislation. Constitutional rights are curtailed. Legal
securities are suspended, freedom of speech is withheld. These
disabilities may either be confined to the disaffected people, in which
case the principle of equal rights disappears, or to save appearances as
to equality they are made universal, in which case general liberty is
impaired. In either event this original condition is set at naught. The
essentials of political liberty are violated. Wise and moderate
statesmanship may mitigate the mischief. Reactionary statesmanship may
inflame it. But the seeds of trouble will always be there as long as the
foreign body is embedded in the organic tissues.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account