The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
History
The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
Home rule -- Ireland; Ireland -- Politics and government
Irish representatives, the number of Irish Unionists during those periods
has never exceeded 23 and has been as low as 19. Thus, putting the various
figures which have been quoted into percentages, it becomes evident that
England has had to live under a Liberal Government when the Unionists (in
1892-5) had 58 per cent. of the total English representation; Scotland has
had to live under a Unionist Government when the Liberals (in 1886-92) had
60 per cent. of the total Scottish representation; whereas Ireland has had
to live under a Unionist Government when the Nationalists had as much as
81 per cent. of the total Irish representation. And it must be borne in
mind that, while England and Scotland are only rarely governed in
opposition to the wishes of the majority of their representatives, Ireland
has continued to be preponderantly Nationalist irrespective of party
fluctuations in Great Britain.
In these circumstances, Ireland, whether in its Nationalist or its
Unionist constituencies, never expresses any other opinion than for or
against Home Rule. We regret the confusion at all elections in the United
Kingdom between Imperial and domestic issues, but at least we get an idea
of the views of the electorate in Great Britain on some big Imperial
question, or as between Free Trade and Protection. In Ireland we get
nothing of the kind; it is impossible to say, for instance, whether
Ireland is in favour of Tariff Reform or not; and the votes of the great
majority of its representatives in the House of Commons are usually given,
not with reference to the views of their constituents on the question
under discussion, but solely in relation to the attainment of Home Rule.
Now, this attitude of the Nationalists is evidently adopted because Irish
domestic concerns are decided in the House of Commons by men who are not
Irish representatives; and it may be remarked that Scotsmen, and even, to
some extent, Englishmen, are also liable to have their wishes on purely
domestic affairs over-ridden by the representatives of the other
countries, but that they do not, on that account, subordinate everything
else to the effort to release themselves from this anomaly.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account