The new state : $b Group organization the solution of popular governmentFollett, Mary Parker
Science
The new state : $b Group organization the solution of popular government
Follett, Mary Parker
Democracy; Political participation; Social psychology; State, The
Let us analyze briefly the advantages of discussion. Genuine discussion
is truth-seeking. First, then, it presses every man to think clearly and
appreciatively and discriminatingly in order to take his part worthily.
What we need above everything else is clear thinking. This need has been
covered over by the demand for “honest” men, but hardly any one would
say to-day, “Give the management of your city over to a group of the
most honest men you can find.” A group of honest men—what a
disconcerting picture the phrase calls up! We want efficient men,
thinking men, as well as honest men. Take care of your thinking and your
morals will take care of themselves—is a present which would have
benefited certain reform campaigns.
The first advantage of discussion then is that it tends to make us think
and to seek accurate information in order to be able to think and to
think clearly. I belong to a civic conference lunch club which meets
once a month to discuss civic questions. On one occasion the program
committee discovered a few days before the luncheon that on the question
to be considered (a certain bill before the legislature), we were all of
the same opinion, and so the discussion did not seem likely to be very
lively. But it happened that our secretary knew some one who was on the
other side, and this woman was therefore invited to be our guest and
present her point of view to us. She accepted with pleasure as she said
she felt strongly on the matter. On the morning of the day of our
meeting, however, she telephoned that she could not come, as she had
just read the bill, thinking it would be wise to do so before she
publicly opposed it, and she found she agreed with it heartily!
Moreover, no one question can be adequately discussed without an
understanding of many more. Remedies for abuses are seldom direct
because every abuse is bound up with our whole political and economic
system. And if discussion induces thinking by the preparation necessary,
it certainly stimulates thinking by the opposition we meet.
But the great advantage of discussion is that thereby we overcome
misunderstanding and conquer prejudice. An Englishman who visited
America last winter said that he had seen in an American newspaper this
advice, “Get acquainted with your neighbor, you might like him,” and was
much struck with the difference between the American and the English way
of looking at the matter. The Englishman, he said, does not get
acquainted with his neighbor for fear he might like him! I sometimes
feel that we refuse to get acquainted with the arguments of our
opponents for fear we might sympathize with them.
Genuine discussion, however, will always and should always bring out
difference, but at the same time it teaches us what to do with
difference. The formative process which takes place in discussion is
that unceasing reciprocal adjustment which brings out and gives form to
truth.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account